Nothing fascinates me more than research and reasoning, something humans do well. They say. I post here about the live method, 6D and what I think research should look like in solution focused living. I also write here about what is wrong with our present research practices and the potentially disastrous consequences. Each title opens to a shorter or longer article.
From curiosity to research
The following pieces are a beautiful illustration of how curiosity can be developed into a more formal and well-founded research career. And why I am so passionate about both. Research is structured curiosity.
Selected artefacts
Lost in the blue bubbles.. Reflection on the lived experience of a person with a learning disability This narrative is a true story of a young boy, however, in order to maintain his and his family and caregivers anonymity I have changed some identifying characteristics such as names of individuals and places of residence.1,2,3 While I tried to remain as true and faithful to the facts and events as possible, his story was undoubtedly influenced by my own observations, emotions and interpretations. The eight weeks I spent with him was particularly intense both physically and emotionally. His journey became a remarkable journey of my self. I gained invaluable experience and knowledge about the life of children with learning disabilities and autistic spectrum disorder, their family and their carers. How they live, what they feel and how the system supports or hinders them. Lost in the Blue Bubbles This is Me. My life story that helps me to express my self and shows you who I am and how I got there. It gives me a voice, reveals my hidden history and hopefully encourages others. You can call me Jack. I am a white British boy born on 10 June 1999. I have severely limited communication skills, therefore my student carer tells you my story. First she was just another stranger, but she quickly discovered how to enter into my world and connect to me. She collected information from several sources, but the most important one remained all along Me. What I said, did, felt and expressed. She was there in the morning when I got up and was waiting for me in the afternoon to get back from school. She spent days with me at home on snowy days, came with me to my school, doctor and youth club. She interviewed my mum, class teacher, teaching assistants – as I am still 1:1 at school – and other support staff. She had numerous discussions with my carers in Lavender House where I live. She also used my past and present care plans, medical records, risk assessments and reports; researched and accessed relevant literature. Although this story of mine is told through her, this is an important work for me to form a bridge between you and me; to show the world from my perspective 4,5,6,7 I am a happy and confident boy, but sometimes I feel insecure. I do not know the word disability, but I am always reminded that I am an outsider. I would like to show you; I would like you to feel, that even if I am different in many ways, really, I am not at all. I am just the same like you – with likes and dislikes, sadness and happiness. But let’s start at the beginning. I am the second child. I have an older brother, Simon, so mum had already had experience of pregnancy and birth. As she recalls, her pregnancy was fine, as was my birth. No signs, nothing suggested that it would be different. I was born and looked like any other newborn. A beautiful bonny baby. I started to breastfeed and seemed to develop normal. But soon things changed. I became restless, hardly slept. Mum could not settle me at all. And I was crying, and screaming all the time. Mum started worrying. We had a lovely health visitor that time, but she did not see anything concerning. My GP also reassured mum, that I just needed more time to get to know the routine. But things did not change. Mum thought that I had intolerance to her breast milk as I was always in horrible discomfort and troubled with my bowels. I must be deaf, she wondered, as I did not turn towards their voices. I looked at her but looked past her, really. I was a lovely boy, but she knew that something was terribly wrong. “He is a bit behind” – they said, “nothing to worry about”. 8 Then at 13 months I received the MMR injection that worsened my condition. I was hospitalised. I got rubella rushes and everything. It was terrible. It was not the MMR that made it, but it inflamed everything. At 16 months, I was not walking or talking. At 18 months, I was starting to move about a bit, but I was quite unsteady. I said odd things that sounded like words, but nothing seemed to work. Mum used to be up all night, sitting with me, holding me and trying to settle me down. 9, 16 It was then when the health visitor became concerned and referred me to Ryegate, a specialist neurology nursing service. Mum was not particularly happy, but they had to do something. They just could not let me carry on crying. So I got the appointment, and I was diagnosed at 18 months: Autistic Spectrum Disorder and Learning Disability. First the shock, then denial and guilt, finally relief. My family got answers and me a chance to get out of my inner misery. We then started to go to Ryegate. Such a massive help for mum, and me. Meeting other mothers with children in a similar situation. I went to Footsteps group three days a week. Eventually, we got the health and social care and the specialist services I needed. But everything remained difficult. Mum used to be a nurse in the local hospital, but she had to give up work. She could not leave me for a second, not for a whole night or so10. My behaviour became steadily worse, and I got the second diagnosis: Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder. Mum tried to learn my communication system that mostly manifested in one or two words, my body posture, a smile or grimace; my challenging behaviour and the frequent cries. I went to Parkwood special needs nursery. The staff was brilliant there, so understanding. They became friends. But I did not change. I was so frustrated and stressed that I used to throw things, and was quite hazardous, really. Then I went to Riverside Special School, but I did not quite like it, either. I was aggressive, smashed things up, furniture and everything. I made myself sick because I knew mum would come and get me. I never had a full week in school. I was suffering. I had no idea what was expected of me. Life was an impatient and irritating place to be. I could say words, but I wanted to communicate. Stop here for a minute and think how powerful communication is for you. Now imagine that you cannot say what you want. Nothing. It is frustrating. It is hardly bearable. When you want to express, let something out. And you can’t. It causes physical and mental pain. It builds up, and up, until it eventually finds its way out. In outbursts, and tantrums.11 My grandma, auntie, the whole family, everybody was so nice to me. They tried to help me, but they could not those days. Friends and neighbours of us were all exceptionally understanding and supportive. But the distress of my inner battle was growing and becoming unbearable. I began to hit myself in frustration – I was hitting my face, head-butting the wall, biting myself and pulling out my hair. I was crying, screaming, and destroying. Everything and everybody. I know I made life very hard. I hurt myself, my family and my little sister, Daisy. I love and always loved my family; I just could not cope with my own mental prison. It came to the point when Daisy was so frightened of me that she hid behind the settee and would not come out. Everything was up side down. My health deteriorated. Mum had not been sleeping in bed for years. Daisy was at risk, my brother disappeared for days. He did not come home from his friend. He just could not cope. Neither my dad. They all loved me, they were just powerless. Whatever they tried nothing seemed to work. In fact, Daisy then was diagnosed as well; she went to the autism team. She could not concentrate, had speech delay. She was so withdrawn, she used to sit and cut her hair off. Her behaviour became shocking. They have done everything, but nothing improved or got better. Mum was physically fighting with me every day. She even overdosed me just to try to help me settle; to get some sleep. To protect me, herself and the rest of my family. She had no other choice left.12 We had a wonderful social worker at that time, an agency social worker. His wife actually had looked after me at Ryegate when I was younger. He was marvellous. He came one day and said to mum: “I will be straight with you, I really worried about the situation and I want you to make a decision. I am worried of your health, and Jack health, and other members of the house. What do you want to do today? I can take Jack in our care while we sort things out.” After so many years mum’s eyes still swim in tears when she tells what happened. “You have to take him” – she cried. I know how much mum loves me; and what sacrifices she and the whole family made. I could not imagine a harder decision for a mum to make. Our hearts were in pieces. However, it was the right decision. I needed special care to reach my potential. The social worker saved all our life.23 So I went to live in a residential home and school, in Barnsley. The consultant there took me off most of the drugs. I still climbed up everything, and dismantled whatever I could but my behaviour and sleeping pattern got better. My bed and chest of drawers remained screwed to the floor however, and windows were locked. Just in case if I wished to move them around. I still went from one extreme to another very quickly, and often felt frustrated and agitated. In spite of that I felt better and I was generally happier. 19 That time fire engines were my obsessions. I always have an obsession. I need them. They make me feel comfortable, they make me believe that I am in control. I loved fire engines so much that once I managed to set the fire alarm off, just to see the fire engines coming and hear the sirens. Well, putting some metal staff in a microwave helped me to get what I wanted. It was funny. I had some more attempts to press the fire alarm but with less success. They had a flashing red light on them that I really liked. I am attracted to bright colours and moving lights that are visually stimulating. I always was. This residential home had a school, I went there every day, but I did not truly enjoy it. My communication through PEC symbols has improved a lot. I can listen to instructions and follow them, but I can easily be distracted. I say words, but usually just the nouns. These are easier for me as they directly relate to pictures.22 And I mostly think in pictures. I often engage in repetitive speech, as it is something I ever so like.17, 18 I like to go out to places, too. Parks, the stations or the Kirklees railway; I love it. And my favourite one: Drayton Manor Park, Land of Thomas. I love trains. I remember one day at school my teacher drew a giant dinosaur on the wall, and all of us in the class had to colour it, paint it a bit. But me, I wrote DRAYTON MANOR across the picture. It looked nice. It was funny actually. My health generally improved that time, but I could still get terrible headaches. If I am in pain, I will tap the part of mine that is causing me trouble and say “hurt, medicine”, or “feel sick”. Sometimes I scream and become very agitated if I have a migraine. I still can make myself sick, but this doesn’t happen very often. I do not really use this way of communication anymore. Then all the sudden I was moved to Rotherham, to a small family house with two other boys. But it turned to be a good thing, only ten minutes away from mum and the family. I have my own room, lots of toys and great staff. They are rather friends, really. They always well care for me, and I am really happy. I used to fuss about food and only ate junk one such as chips, hamburger, crisps and sweets. Nowadays I eat much healthier. Although I have a sensitive hearings and cannot stand noise and loud sounds, I love crunchy food that can be really loud inside when you eat it. I also like my routines. The structure. At home and in the school. I am not good at changes at all. I am independent now in many things but still need prompting at times. I can make a drink, get dressed or have a bath independently. Actually I love bath. And water generally. Swimming or playing in the garden in the mini pool. I did not always enjoy it, though. There were times when I hated the water on my face, or when you rinsed my hair. I used to flap my hands and shout: “Oh no, help Jack!” I always say Jack. I do not know that I should call myself I. So I can do things on my own. I am 14 in a day or two. Talking about being 14 I also started to discover my body. Staff is superb, they just firmly remind me that I have my personal space in my bedroom. Although I do things independently, they can take a lot of time to me. Like to get dressed in the morning. Not because I have decided that I will annoy you but because I do not quite understand what the fuss is about. There are so many much more fascinating things around such as my trains than putting on my socks. And anyway, why is this hurry! 5 minutes to get dressed, another 10 to have breakfast. Make no sense to me. Time does not make great sense to me anyway. I can spend hours of wondering on things. I am quite good at deciding what I want to eat or wear, though. I am able to tell you what I like and dislike, and can make my own choices.13 I love cooking and chopping food, too. However, you have to be careful because the kettle fascinates me. I love when you put the kettle on. A bright, blue light comes on. The water starts moving around slowly, shattering the light into thousands of glittery rays. The bubbles become bigger and bigger, spreading the blue rays all over. It is a miracle. My miracle. I love lose myself in these miracles. Lost in the blue bubbles… I often become hypnotised. I can lose myself in anything actually – in the spots or sounds, in the words of people around me. I am too happy losing myself. However, I also enjoy different activities. Mainly the ones that are based around my learning. I love my jigsaw, laptop and iPod. I am actually pretty good at computer. I read, surf the net, stream music and video and use the Word. I can change the font size and colour, type and erase words. I can cut pictures from the web, insert them to Word then print out my favourite piece of art. This is something I am glad to have and hopefully can build upon. When the weather is better, I love playing with sand and water in the garden. I throw it up in the air and just laugh. Then mix it with water and run it through my fingers. I use various objects to fill up with the wet sand. Once I began throwing the wet sand on the floor and then at the house. Staff asked me stop doing it, but I just could not do it. “I can’t stop, it’s too fun”-I am giggled in a high-pitched voice. I stopped, eventually. I try to keep myself busy and entertained, you see. I love YouTube. Watching films, rewinding and rewinding certain sounds and sequences. I love iPods and iPhones, too, so you have to be careful. Once I turned my mum’s iPhone into Spanish. It was funny, she had no idea what to do. My student carer also knows it now. She left her bag with me for a minute. It was enough for me to take out her laptop, and log in. You should have seen her face. It took her a good few minutes to understand what had just happened. She loves her gadgets, too. And she has plenty. That day I had no internet on my laptop. It made me extremely agitated. For a reason, I allowed her to touch my laptop that I do not often do. But it was worth it. She made internet for me. We connected and started a relationship. In the end, it is not that difficult to gain my trust and connect to me. I can connect to people, you just have to understand me. That words are not the only way to communicate with me. When we are watching films together, listening to music or playing with my laptop; we connect. And we talk. Just without words. You feel me, and I feel you. And it is good. I do not feel isolated and unsecured anymore. Holding your hand, or resting my head on your shoulder can make me feel really good. I like people’s company but on my own special way. When I want it and the way I want it. I can handle some sort of touch and cuddles. It is nice sometimes. I sometimes speak loud and make noises. Even if it makes sense to you, it does not necessarily mean that I want to talk to you. I actually very clearly can express if I do not want to talk to you or I do not like the noises around by putting my fingers into my ears. Then sometimes I talk to you and tell you what I would like to get or do. “Sheffield, station, car, blue car”. I can be highly vocal when I am excited, so, please do not be frightened by me. Join in and have fun with me. I still can be challenging, usually when I cannot do or do not want to do something. However, I am getting better and better every day at controlling my frustration. Last time I tried to put lots of toys into my school bag. When the student carer asked me not to do it I became very agitated. I calmed down myself, however, I started to bite my hand right away. I do it every time when I am excited or upset. I am still proud, though, because I am getting there. And I won at the end anyway. I managed to put at least some of the toys into my bag. Pinching things and sticking them into my pockets belong to me. I have a special school in Rotherham, I go there every day. And I love it. I have an active school life and my learning progress is good. I can write and spell correctly, however, my handwriting is quite poor. I was around 4 when my mum bought some fridge magnet letters for me. I could not talk, but spell the world Telly Tubbies perfectly. I loved letters, and learnt them quickly. My reading is very good. My maths is not brilliant but I do basic counts, and try to be familiar with coins. I like science: modelling, balancing, building and plastering. My favourite subject is still the ICT and using the smart board. School is good, but I need help. I occasionally lose focus and need some reminder of what I am supposed to be doing. I like to do lots of different things at the same time and can get migraines if concentrating too long. I get on well with everybody, and I work terribly hard. I love when I can go out and stick cards on the board to explain the day, date or weather outside. When I do it well, they all clap. It makes me smile and feel proud. Since living in Rotherham again, I go home once or twice a week. It was after 3 years, that I could visit my family house again. I recognised it immediately. Everything. How I could forget my loving home I used to live. The shed in the garden where I used to play. Some of my toys and old train tracks are still there for me. I loved spending a lot of time with a jolly old video player, the VHS. I loved it. I still have it, and the cupboard is full of videos. My family contact is really important to me. “Mum, Dad, Daisy, Simon. Jack home for tea”. I love all of them. I truly do. My grandma and great-grandma. She is 97 you know. She is real funny. According to my mum her secret is the hard work and a pint of Guinness every day. Oh, and Ralph. My brother’s dog. I love him. He is interesting because he is a real naughty. He runs and jumps on everybody but not on me. Never. He just follows me around and sits next to me. He knows something. He must know. So I am totally OK with the situation. I am quite lucky actually. I have two homes. When time comes, and I have to go back to Lavender House, I do. I have more toys now there, than at home, anyway. And you just cannot believe it. Daisy symptoms all gone! Symptoms of autism and her withdrawn behaviour all gone. All of them. She is on the normal level of her age now. Actually, she is a very chatty little girl. She is doing right well at school. It just shows how difficult it was for everybody. 20, 21 Now we get on well, very well. She likes my place and my carers. We eat tea together, and she helps me. We are all sorted now. Here I am. A real teenager, who tries people out, discovers his boundaries. I live in a residential home and have a loving family. I go to school and improve my skills. I have good days and bad days. I laugh, and I cry. Just like you. I have a good life, a happy life because I have a good network, a fantastic mum, and a loving family who gave me a secure attachment and the right care to my needs. A rock solid foundation that I can build upon.14 I hope that my journey showed you that although we function on another level, our life could be still full. A place filled with innocent wonder, open space and unfolded dreams. Our emotions are simpler. We are vulnerable, and probably will be forever. We will get lost without the right support. But all we need are mentors who can help us to make sense of your world. 15 All we need is you; who see us and not our condition. It is OK to be different, you know. I hope that if you understand our world better, you will be less frightened and will come closer to us. All we want is, to be free. To be who we meant to be. This is Me. References 1. TOPSS ENGLAND (2004). The National Occupational Standards for Social Work. [online] Last accessed 15 December 2012 at: http://www.skillsforcare.org.uk/developing_skills/National_Occupational_Standards/social_work_NOS.aspx 2. NMC (2008). The code: Standards of conduct, performance and ethics for nurses and midwives. [online]. Last accessed 12 December 2012 at: http://www.nmc-uk.org/Documents/Standards/The-code-A4-20100406.pdf 3. HCPC (2012). Standards of conduct, performance and ethics. [online]. Last accessed 12 December 2012 at: http://www.hpcuk.org/assets/documents/10003B6ES tandardsofconduct,performanceandethics.pdf. 4. MCCLIMENS, Alex (2002). ‘All I can remember were tablets’ Pat’s story [online] Journal of Learning Disabilities, 6 (1) 73-88, Article from SHU at https://shuspace.shu.ac.uk/@@/AE65FED38023D40417701BDCF19C3F11/courses/1/66-4878-00S-A-20123/content/_3881622_1/alex%20pat%27s%20story.pdf 5. Hewitt, Helen (2006). Life story books for people with learning disabilities: a practical guide. London, UK, BILD 6. Meininger, Herman P (2006). Narrating, writing, reading: life story work as an aid to (self) advocacy [online] Journal compilation, 34,181-188. Article from Wiley last accessed 3 April 2013 at http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com.lcproxy.shu.ac.uk/store/10.1111/ j.14683156.2006.00416.x/asset/j.14683156.2006.00416.x.pdf?v=1&t=hf3wxth1&s=27f81d50279ffb8eb7b2c541e212447194a4a0d6 7. Gibson, Faith (2011) Reminiscence and Life Story Work : A Practice Guide. (4th ed.) [online] London, Jessica Kingsley Publishers. Last accessed on 28 March 201 at http://www.dawsonera.com/depp/reader/protected/external/AbstractView/S9780857003386 8. Tantam, Digby (2012) Autism spectrum disorders through the life span. London, Jessica Kingsley. 9. Booy, R; Bedford, H; Elliman, D; Sengupta, N. (2004) Does the MMR triple vaccine cause autism? [online] Evidence-based Healthcare and Public Health, 8, (5) 239–245. Article from Science Direct. Accessed 3 April 2013 at http://www.sciencedirect.com.lcproxy.shu.ac.uk/science/article/pii/S1744224904001196 10. BROMLEY, Jo; HARE, Dougal Julian; DAVISON Kerry; EMERSON, Eric (2004) Mothers supporting children with autistic spectrum Disorders. Social support, mental health status and satisfaction with services [online] Article from Sage at http://aut.sagepub.com.lcproxy.shu.ac.uk/content/8/4/409.full.pdf+html 11. Frith, Uta (2008). Autism: a very short introduction [online] Oxford University Press. Last accessed 4 April 2013 at http://www.dawsonera.com/depp/reader/protected/direct/SearchResults,buttons.eBookView.sdirect?sp=S9780191548802 12. Rivers, Jessica Wood and Stoneman, Zolinda (2003). Sibling Relationships when a Child Has Autism: Marital Stress and Support Coping [online]. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, 33, (4). Article from Springer at http://link.springer.com.lcproxy.shu.ac.uk/content/pdf/10.1023%2FA%3A1025006727395 13. Brewster, Jacqui; Ramcharan, Paul (2005) Enabling and supporting person-centred approaches. In Grant, Gordon; Goward, Peter; Richardson, Malcolm; Ramcharan, Paul (eds.) (2005). Learning Disability. A life cycle approach to valuing people. Maidenhead, Open University Press. 491-514. 14. HOWE, David (2011) Attachment across the lifecourse : a brief introduction, Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke, UK 15. Richardson, Malcolm (1997) Reflection and celebration — Neal (1960-1987): narrative of a young man with profound and multiple disabilities. Journal of Intellectual Disabilities, 1, 191. Article from SHU at https://shuspace.shu.ac.uk/@@/AE65FED38023D40417701BDCF 19C3F11/courses/1/66-4878-00S-20123/content/_3881622_1/neil%20a%20celebration.pdf 16. Anderberg, Dan; Chevalier, Arnaud; Wadsworth, Jonathan (2011) Anatomy of a health scare: Education, income and the MMR controversy in the UK. Journal of Health Economics, 30, (3), Pages 515–530. Article from Science Direct at http://www.sciencedirect.com.lcproxy.shu.ac.uk/science/article/pii/S0167629611000154 17. Mandy, William P.L.; Skuse, David H. (2008) Research Review: What is the association between the social-communication element of autism and repetitive interests, behaviours and activities? Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry 49 (8) pp 795–808. Article from Wiley at http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com.lcproxy.shu.ac.uk/store/10.1111/j.1469-7610.2008.01911.x/asset/j.14697610.2008.01911.x.pdf?v=1&t=hf411idr&s=e1215f7ddac465b34cc590cd14575782a356085b 18. Lewis, Mark H; Bodfish, W. James (1998) REPETITIVE BEHAVIOR DISORDERS IN AUTISM MENTAL RETARDATION AND DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES RESEARCH REVIEWS, 4,80–89. Article from Wiley at http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com.lcproxy.shu.ac.uk/store/10.1002/(SICI) 1098-2779(1998)4:2%3C80::AID-MRDD4%3E3.0.CO;2-0/asset/4_ftp.pdf?v=1&t=hf41434x&s=edfded441d12515fffd270c1c3bedb77db0cca4d 19. Emerson, Eric and Einfeld, Stewrard L. (2011) Challenging Behaviour (3 ed) [online] Cambridge University Press. Last accessed 27 March 2013 at http://lib.myilibrary.com.lcproxy.shu.ac.uk/Open.aspx?id=300607 20. Ferraioli , Suzannah J; Harris, Sandra L. (2009) The Impact of Autism on Siblings Social Work in Mental Health, 8, (1) Special Issue: Critical Transitions in the Lives of Young People with Autism Spectrum Disorders pages 41-53. Article from Tandfonline at http://www.tandfonline.com.lcproxy.shu.ac.uk/doi/full/10.1080/15332980902932409 21. Schieve, Laura A., Blumberg, Stephen J. Rice, Catherine; Visser, Susanna N.; Boyle, Coleen (2007)The Relationship Between Autism and Parenting Stress PEDIATRICS, 119, pp. S114 -S121. Article from Pediatrics at http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/119/Supplement_1/S114.full 22. Thurman, Sue; Jones, Jane; Tarleton, Berth (2005). Without words – meaningful information for people with high individual communication needs [online] British Journal of Learning Disabilities, 33, 83–89 Article from SHU at https://shuspace.shu.ac.uk/@@/AE65FED38023D40417701BDCF19C3F11/courses/1/66-4878-00S-A-20123/content/_3881618_1/PMLD%20communication.pdf. 23. Williams, Paul (2007). Social Work with people with learning difficulties. Learning Matters, Exeter
“If only, some say, we could do without any labels. How so much better, purer, faster our access to God, to Nature, to Truth, to Science could be.” To which other voices (or sometimes the same) answer: “Alas (or fortunately), we cannot do without labels, intermediaries, mediators of all shapes and forms, because this is the only way to access God, Nature, Truth and Science”. (Latour 2002 p14) “To label, or not to label: that is the question” (Hamlet 3.1.64-65). What if is it this very question that paralyses us? LabelClash reflects this uncertainty: without further investigation, we cannot establish whether labelling is beneficial or harmful. This extract from my essay will briefly explore what has made labelling, a mediation of hidden disabilities (by hidden disabilities the writer means intellectual disabilities, autism spectrum disorders and mental health disorders) the focus of so much debate and will attempt to go beyond the labelling wars “to document, to fathom and maybe, to overcome the quandary of labelling” (Latour 2002 p14) by the critical application of Bruno Latour and Jean Baudrillard major ideas. The essay was inspired by an exhibition: “IconoClash. Beyond the Image Wars in Science, Religion and Art”. The show and the accompanying book introduced by Latour’s words aimed to portray that “we cannot do without representation; if only we could do without representation”; a contradictory drive of producing and destroying images that have always characterised science, art, religion as well as politics (ZKM 2005). The complex phenomenon of labelling offers an account on what labelling symbolises that generates so much passion. Foucault (2006/1961) classic work, the History of Madness walk us through the political, medical and cultural construction of madness from the Middle Ages through the Classical period to Modernity. Foucault displayed that madness has never been a natural phenomenon, a universal truth discovered by the scientists, but the labelling of hidden disabilities depended on how the phenomenon was experienced by a particular society. The development of labelling can also be illustrated through Baudrillard “The Three Orders of Simulacra” (Buadrillard 1993 p50) and Latour’s (1993) description of the pre-moderns and moderns to appreciate modernity with its challenges. In the field of hidden disabilities, Modernity in its totality, the third order of Simulacra, the Code-governed era can be marked by the 6th International Classification of Diseases (ICD-6, WHO, 1949 and DSM-I, APA, 1952) that included mental disorders the first time. The labelling of hidden disabilities became complete and started its journey to the universal through the networks of institutions and professionals: the manuals made official and scientific, in other words, irreversibly “real” the distinction between normal and abnormal, neurotypical and disordered (Latour 1993). Once the templates of the different disorders are created, it can be replicated. It is no longer manually reproduced through the long and laborious observations of the patients but “conceived according to their very reproducibility, their diffraction from a generative core called model” (Baudrillard 1993 p56). Or as Latour (1993 p242,259) puts it, once all the earlier tests, descriptions and arguments become incorporated into a black box called ICD or DSM influenced by the credibility of the professionals involved it separates labels from their creation; they become a “prototype … to carry out most of the initial interpretations … whilst alternatives become prohibitive”. These distinctions and their organisations into manuals will ultimately develop into an even more powerful way of control as the common origin and the whole process become invisible: “it is not men who make Nature; Nature has always existed …we are only discovering its secrets. Human beings, and only human beings, are the ones who construct society and freely determine their own destiny” (Latour 1979 p75). Nature and Society become the explanations of hidden disabilities as they do not have to be explained anymore (Latour 1993). Once a condition is converted to a taken-for-granted fact, even if its description originally contained various modalities (Latour 1979), representations of hidden disabilities slowly become more often replaced by simulation: the various conditions will be generated by their relations to other labels and by the different images of the same label losing their connection with the origin. “Representation does not cease or become impossible, it even remains dominant, but simulation becomes increasingly prevalent” (Pawlett 2007 p77). Latour (1979 p177) argues that once a label begins to stabilise, reality will be attributed to the newly born label until the label becomes the reason why the observation has started in the first place. “At the onset of stabilisation, the label was the virtual image of the condition; subsequently, the condition becomes the mirror image of the reality out there”. Both arguing that labels do not equate with an external and objective “madness” but the constructed reality of people born with a set of specificities (Law and Hassard 2009). The reality of labelling, “its objectivity and its materiality derives solely from the separation of man and nature, of a body and a non-body” (Baudrillard 1994 p133). “Nature and Society must remain absolutely distinct” (Latour 1993 p32). “Choose! Either a fact is real or it’s fabricated!” (Latour 2007 p91). Numerous academics have also critically observed the negative consequences of the separation of nature-nurture in labelling. Behavioural geneticists and medical sociologists were influential to attempt the bridge this gap. The former coined contemporary theories such as the gene–environment correlation and interaction (Rutter 2008), whilst the latter formulated labelling theory (Becker 1963). Behavioural geneticists aim to define neuropsychological vulnerabilities and their cumulative reciprocal interaction with society (Plomin et al. 2010), as in most cases genes operate together with the environment as part of a multifactorial causation (Rutter 2011). However, Latour critiques these theories claiming they perceive impairments as a mixture of two pure forms as they split a complex phenomenon apart to attempt to extract what came from society such as parenting or education and what came from nature such as the genes and neurotransmitters. Then they multiply the intermediaries, concepts, professions and other elements to rebuild the integrity they destroyed. Scientists know that nature and society are not fundamentally distinct forms but as long as those intermediaries are displayed as mixtures of pure elements, the illusion of a modern world can be maintained. Although modern Western psychiatry has become one of the most holistic disciplines, its practitioners rely on the medical approach heavily. Conversely, most hidden disabilities are entangled with the collective, objects, opportunities and constraints (Hauser et al. 2006; Gomart and Hennion 1999). This is reflected in the “missing heritability” phenomenon, the fact that science failed to identify the gene variants that supposed to underline to varying degrees most hidden disabilities (Chaufan and Joseph 2013). It was not long after hidden disabilities became distinct labels in the manuals that labelling theory became prominent highlighting the possible adverse effects of labels on the individuals and the reinforcement of stereotypies. Howard S. Becker, a leading theorist of the field, argued that labels reflected the view of the majorities about minorities who were perceived being deviant from cultural norms. Once labelled, individuals must adapt to the labels and the consequences of labelling (Paternoster and Bachman 2013). Labelling theory has challenged the categories as true representations of phenomenon and showed the role of status in the process. However, they failed to consider the wider influencing factors (Plummer 1979). Psychologists argue that labelling practices are valid in determining dysfunction but hardly effective in identifying strengths and weaknesses (Koriakin et al. 2013, Lebeer et al. 2011). Whilst more recently some advocate that labelling, a multifaceted phenomenon, should reflect an integrated model incorporating the biological, environmental and individual elements (Shakespeare 2006, Ward and Beech 2006). Whilst integration is a promising collaboration, Baudrillard argues there is no evidence that it does more than reducing uncertainty. Latour certainly agrees as long as integration means that the work of mediation remains forbidden no matter how many disciplines are involved. Yet, without labelling can we provide care, support, or positive discrimination? How can we research and improve our interventions without an agreed terminology? It causes great difficulties across disciplines that various frameworks exist including the different legislation. Rutter and Uher (2012) extensively discussed these challenges. Conversely, Latour and Baudrillard argue that one of the weaknesses of these theories are that they base their argument on either nature or culture, on binary oppositions, and then take into account, if at all, the effects of/on the other pole. For behavioural geneticists, medical sociologists, psychologists or educational professionals Nature and Culture already exist to explain disabilities, the hybrids, constructed in the constant interaction between humans, objects and signs. “In medical sociology… the theory must specify …the effects of these biological phenomena on the human social condition or, conversely, the effects of social factors on these phenomena” (Cockerham 2007 p291,292). “However, what if neither Nature nor Society offers sound theories to interpret phenomenon, but are what is to be explained? If “Nature and Society are part of the problem, not part of the solution”? (Latour 1993 p95) Labels are constructed by laboratories, medical journals, conferences and many other inscription devices or in short for Baudrillard by the Code; to create order out of disorder to keep the disorders ordered without employing any pre-existing order (Latour 1979 p257). Hidden disabilities are dis/orders: schizophrenia spectrum disorder, bipolar disorder, autism spectrum disorder. The word, disorder, was first used around the 15th century and the Oxford dictionary defines it as a “confused or messy state… lot of noise… a condition that is not normal”. Precisely why the system is so fascinated by labelling: they have to stabilise, reduce uncertainty, make disorders predictable. “Labels replace the lived relation; they present a coded, stereotyped version of reality, one that is more manageable, less threatening but also less meaningful or intense than the world of symbolic ambivalence” (Pawlett 2007 p15). Labelling reflects the widespread assumption that all phenomena of life draw a graphic account. Order is the rule, therefore disorders have no place in politics, ethics or science. This has been challenged by both Latour and Baudrillard who claim that preceding theories of totality are no longer plausible, but indeterminacy, fluidity and multiplicity. The ultimate aim of labelling is one form of social control as hidden disabilities have the potential to disturb the order even if order itself is constructed by the system, mere illusion. Hidden disabilities share many characteristics with complex systems; however, whilst scientists are interested in complexity as its unpredictability is puzzling, hidden disabilities must be cured, normalised and controlled. Therefore, by the middle of the 20th century, the signs of hidden disabilities were turned into the sickness of otherness and its medicalisation. How does modernity turn otherness into labels? Before a condition becomes part of the diagnostic manuals it takes a long journey from recognition through observations to labels. Autism, for example as most people know, first came to the attention to Leo Kranner and Hans Asperger psychiatrists in the early 20th century as “fascinating peculiarities” (1943, 1944). Yet it is already too easy to attribute it all to these people and forget that if “we say of a man that he has moved a mountain, it is because he has been credited with the work of the crowd that he claimed to command but that he also followed” (Latour 1988 p22). All these long descriptions once stabilised by the “chosen”, the scientists “who can go back and forth from one world to the other …. the passageway closed to all others” (Latour 2004 p11) will become the truth in the diagnostic manuals. The diagnosis to work must be as specific as possible they say, hence theories evolve and the political and scientific debate continue that are reflected in the changes of those labels. The redesigned labels illustrate that labelling is not a clear cut science but serve the actual interest of society leading to an ever greater abyss between how labelling perceived by the professionals representing the system and by the individuals with specificities. Latour (1999 p19) highlights that “actors know what they do … it is us, the social scientists, who lack knowledge of what they do, and not they who are missing the explanation of why they are unwittingly manipulated by forces exterior to themselves”. But does the system permit this interaction? Certainly not according to Baudrillard: “The hegemony exercised by the capitalist system is based on its power to give… all without possibility of reciprocation.” And “if no reciprocal exchange is possible, we remain imprisoned in the structure of power and abstraction” (Pawlett 2013 p95). Baudrillard claims that this confusion, label or not to label, the apparently simultaneous truth claims are rooted in binary oppositions that simulate reality to ultimately join all of us in the cycle of consumption. Latour argues that the moderns by inventing this dichotomy reduced complexities into distinct entities giving rise not only to myriad accounts as Baudrillard highlighted but also initiating an endless debate that goes far beyond labelling: advocacy services, experts by experience, equality legislation on one side, geneticists, hospitals, and anti-psychotics on the other. The NHS, nurses, psychiatrists called Nature treat and medicalise, the Local Authority, social workers, teachers called Culture empower and socialise. How can the NHS define itself as global and medical when the whole living body depends on the social relations of its workers and what flows in their local networks; and how can the Local Authority says that they are neither medical nor global when their very system is based on thresholds and intelligence and what flows in the networks of the global Leviathan? And in–between we find the hybrids; people living with hidden disabilities, the result of a complex interaction between Nature, Culture, Discourse and perhaps the Crossed-out God. And when one questions the politics behind, they cover all possibilities: Power resides in either Nature or Society; we can move from one explanation to the other, but they cannot be mixed. God is present of course but without any power to intervene. The perception of labelling then depends on whether someone was cured or killed, abused or loved, but they move from case to case with such a speed that they can never be confronted. “All the sciences natural and social are now mobilised to turn the humans into so many puppets manipulated by objective forces which only the natural or social scientists happen to know” (Latour 1993 p75). Just as Latour (1997) describes how autism becomes a statement leaving out everything that had a role in its construction, Baudrillard (1993 p63) claims that tests, regularly used to establish a diagnosis, are the perfect simulation as the questions have already examined reality, and only asked those questions to which it has responded. In modernity everything is commonly based on models, one version of yes/no binary tests, yet again without any reciprocity. Can we confirm or dispute any of these disorders without the networks, inscription devices and those tests? Accordingly, both Baudrillard and Latour argue that identity cannot be found in a person but it exists in relations to others (Currie 1998). But until Baudrillard claims that it is the Code that produces identity by creating the structure of difference based on binary oppositions such as neurotypical and atypical, Latour claims that identities are constructed out of circulating plug-ins that we constantly have to download, install and activate. Baudrillard argues that the system gives us the gifts of self, and labelling has a major role in this. These gifts prohibit responses; they can only be accepted. We can try to resist it and many people do: they do not go for assessments, or refuse the diagnosis or accept it but do not disclose it or use more drastic means. However, resistance can result in compensation and the development of secondary mental ill-health such as anorexia/bulimia or drug/alcohol misuse that are very prevalent amongst people with hidden disabilities. This is a key part of the criteria: diagnosis is given if the individual needs it to manage his/her otherness, in other words, to fit in the system. In the end, how long can one pretend to be “normal”? A label of hidden disabilities is then many times a way to reject the system by fitting in. But this duality according to Baudrillard is important, and we need to maintain a self for the system and another outside of it by hyper-conformity, which then can be converted to radical otherness. Is labelling beneficial or harmful? Labelling can help people living with certain specificities who might need a different code to gain access to their otherness and to learn what flows in the networks, and how the different plug-ins and the Code affect them. Otherwise, they might remain too vulnerable. Not labels as static and simplistic categories, but labels as fluid and dynamic work-nets that are open to change; a liberating insight. Not a map that precedes the territory, a precession of simulacra, a hyperreal (Baudrillard 1993 p1), and not a map either that with some a priori decisions have already chosen the true size of the territory (Latour 2007). But a compass, a pencil, a rubber and blank pages giving individuals full freedom to deploy any shape and size; using as many mediators as possible to explore the myriad connections to render every journey visible into a unique atlas to one’s unrepeatable world. But not the Atlas that must be read from left to right, from top to bottom, but an atlas that has been placed in space, providing the traveller with countless perspectives. However, it is not that simple. Where do we draw the border between a hidden disability and a personality? If one has a tantrum, is it the result of stress or the label? At what age should labels be given without risking originality and creating “corrected, rectified humans”? (Baudrillard 2005 p27). If you are doing well how can you ensure that the system will not make an icon of you? But if you refuse to be showcased, can you give voice to the voiceless? Latour (2002 p17) takes us beyond the paradoxes: if you show the hand of the human at work, you are ruining objectivity, but to prove that all this is not fabrication you need to insist that no human hand has ever touched hidden disabilities. LabelClash argues that the more evident the hand of the human at work, and the more images, mediations, intermediaries are openly constructed, the better our understanding of phenomenon becomes (Latour 2002 p17). And when all the elements become visible, they can be traced back to their origin just to show that they have never been there. They were always images. We were all given symbolic identities by the system, labels are just a form of them. Baudrillard argues “never question others about their identity…[t]here is no such thing as oneself…everything comes from the Other (Baudrillard 1993b cited in Pawlett 2013 p143). Latour certainly shares Baudrillard’s view, the core of ANT, that nothing exists in isolation but in relation to others and things. Our identity comes in pieces; we build it up bit by bit. “Have we been made up? Of course…” (Latour 2007 p213). Some people will be more susceptible for certain plug-ins than others, and people with hidden disabilities have the tendency to download incompatible plug-ins or activate them at the wrong time as things are modelled by and to the majority. Is labelling then a way to manage people who are more difficult to integrate? Otherwise they would remain too unpredictable? Do some people choose to be labelled to have a ‘legitimate stance’ against the system? To belong? To hide? To provoke? To justify? To forget? To Be? Modernity seems to turned things upside down; naiveté became wrongdoing; people are labelled disabled because of their inability to maintain the artificial social rules. Some hurt because they are childlike; they lack a competitive ego, and many of the traits worshipped by the moderns. They represent a symbolic existence, constantly reminding us of our sins and illusions. Others tend to ruin the games of the adults; they tell you the end of the book. Some talk to themselves. Others hear voices. Whilst most of them render the invisible visible. Their openness injures. Sometimes they hurt because they remind us of our vulnerabilities; sometimes because they are unpredictable by turning intermediaries to mediators; they disturb the order. People do not want to put on the glasses: “truth can be painful, can shatter many of your illusions … freedom hurts” (Zizek 2013). And sometimes they hurt because they are dangerously similar, and as Pawlett (2013 p132) highlights it includes those whose peculiarities were cured or denied or taken. Moreover, it includes the very people with different labels or with different abilities of the same label. They themselves stigmatise just as people without labels do. Legislation as well as our changing terminologies feed these illusions by insisting for the vulnerable to be heard and labelled creating an artificial tolerance, the calm before the storm. The paradox of modernity is that the more science advances and the more we worship the rational mind, the more illusory the universe come to be and the more we learn that we are not capable of understanding the true nature of reality. Humans are too entangled and deep for the rational mind to succeed. The moderns, therefore, thrive on proliferation, binary oppositions and on the battle of the “isms”. As there is no such thing as hybrids, and certainly no superposition. Yet, you are constantly forced to open the box to decide whether the cat is dead or alive. Baudrillard (1993 p126) claims that this separation of life and death into a binary opposition is the ultimate control and all the rest flows from it including labelling. “Exclusion is not of the mad but the dead … The spectre of death haunts life as the spectre of madness haunts sanity, disorder threatens order”. Latour (1993,2007) and Baudrillard (1993) offer that most explanation is asymmetrical that gives the fundamental power to the system: capitalism and consumer, life and death, science and politics, nature and social, madness and sanity. Do we have to maintain that hidden disability is sometimes an object, a social bond, and a discourse? Or that it is a bit of each? If we aim to understand the quandary of labelling, these are the dilemmas we need to overcome. Or Baudrillard and Latour suggest, bypass them. ANT has the potential to bring the hybrids to light by tracing the actants, whilst according to Baudrillard we can practice symbolic exchange, hyper-conformity and radical otherness. The brief argument aimed to illustrate that labelling is just the tip of the iceberg. We have seen that Moderns with separating the object of science from the subject of law not only created bars between the normal and abnormal, but between the medical and the social, nature and culture, risk factors and protective factors, capacity and unwise decisions, nurses and social workers, the NHS and the Local Authority. How can we go ahead? By going back to the networks that construct irreversibility and reversibility as in the symbolic operation the reciprocity of life and death entails their exchange in a social cycle. We need to respect hidden disabilities as hybrids, where neither of the elements has an independent and inherent existence. Labels have to become mediators that transform and not merely transport. Both Latour and Baudrillard argue that we need to move beyond the abstractions of theories. We need practical tools with the involvement of various professionals that could be traced, followed and altered. And hybrid professionals who have the potential to bridge the differing code of conducts, access relevant information from multiple sources, and have the ability to turn intermediaries into mediators, whether it is pooled budget or policy. Nature, society and discourse do not define hidden disabilities but what circulates in the networks: people, objects, words, signs… The networks cross domains: “they are simultaneously discursive, narrated, passionate, and peopled with actants of autonomous forms. They are uncertain, existential, and never forget Being” (Latour 1993 p24). Symbolic acts, the cycle of giving and receiving functions through the collective and can strengthen communities by suspending the binary oppositions of abled/disabled, normal/abnormal and the dominant Code. Symbolic is open, spontaneous and authentic; something that has always characterised people with hidden disabilities. Once we understand labels, ours and others, we can shift towards radical otherness; not the opposite of labels but singularity, a state beyond the code and all comparisons (Pawlett 2013 p143). Nothing- is definitive - or rather everything is. Every stage of evolution, every age of life, every moment of life, every animal or plant species, is perfect in itself. Every character, in its singular imperfection, in its matchless finitude, is incomparable. (Baudrillard 2005 p140) REFERENCES APA, American Psychiatric Association (2013) DSM-5, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, APA, USA Asperger H. (1944/1991) ‘Autistic psychopathy’ in childhood. In: Cambridge: Cambridge University Press p. 37-92. Baudrillard J. (1993) Symbolic exchange and death. London: Sage Publications Baudrillard J. (1993b) The Transparency of Evil: Essays on Extreme Phenomena. London: Verso Books Baudrillard J. (1994) Simulacra and simulation. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan PressBaudrillard J. (2005) The Intelligence of Evil: or, The Lucidity Pact. Bloomsbury, UK Becker, H. S. (1963) Outsiders: Studies in the sociology of deviance. New York: Free Press Chaufan C, Joseph J. (2013) The ‘Missing Heritability’ of Common Disorders: Should Health Researchers Care? International Journal of Health Services. 43(2):281-303. Cockerham WC. (2007) A Note on the Fate of Postmodern Theory and its Failure to Meet the Basic Requirements for Success in Medical Sociology. Social Theory & Health. 5(4):285-96. Currie M. (1998) Postmodern narrative theory. Basingstoke: Macmillan Press Foucault M (2006) History of madness. Abingdon, Routledge Gomart, Hennion (1999) A sociology of attachment: music amateurs, drug users in Law J, Hassard J. Actor network theory and after. Malden, MA;Oxford [England];Blackwell/Sociological Review Hauser Stuart T, Allen Joseph P, Golden Eve (2006) in Bers (2008) Out of the Woods: Tales of Resilient Teens. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, USA Koriakin Taylor A, McCurdy Mark D, Papazoglou Aimilia, Pritchard Alison E, T Andrew, Zabel, E Mark Mahone, Lisa A Jacobson (2013) “Classification of intellectual disability using the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children: Full Scale IQ or General Abilities Index?” Developmental medicine and child neurology, vol. 55, no. 9, pp. 840-845. Latour B (1988) Pasteurization of France Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press Latour b (1999) On recalling ANT in Law J, Hassard J. (1999) Actor network theory and after. Malden, MA; Oxford [England]: Blackwell/Sociological Review Latour B (2004) Politics of nature: how to bring the sciences into democracy. Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press Latour B, Weibel P (2002) Iconoclash: beyond the image wars in science, religion, and art. Karlsruhe, London, Cambridge, ZKM Latour B, Woolgar S. (1979) Laboratory Life. Princeton University Press Latour B. (1993) We Have Never Been Modern. Harvard UP Latour B. (1996) On actor-network theory: A few clarifications. Soziale Welt. 47(4):369-81. Latour B.(2007) Reassembling the social: an introduction to actor–network–theory. Oxford: Oxford University Press Law J, Hassard J. (1999) Actor network theory and after. Malden, MA; Oxford Lebeer, J., Sønnesyn, G., Candeias, A.A., Demeter, K., Birta-Székely, N., Partanen, P., McGlynn M. (2005) Idiots, lunatics and the royal prerogative in early Tudor England. The Journal of Legal History. 26(1):1-24. Paternoster R, Bachman R. (2013) Labeling Theory. CriminologyPawlett W. (2007) Jean Baudrillard: against banality. London: Routledg Pawlett W. (2013) Violence, Society and Radical Theory: Bataille, Baudrillard and Contemporary Society. Ashgate Publishing Group Plomin R, DeFries JC, Knopik VS, Neiderhiser JM (2013) Behavioural genetics 6th ed. New York, Worth Publishers Plummer, K (1979) Misunderstanding Labeling Perspectives, in David Downes and Paul Rock, eds (1979) Deviant Interpretations, Oxford, Martin Roberston Rutter, M (2011). Research Review: Child psychiatric diagnosis and classification: concepts, findings, challenges and potential. [online]. Journal of child psychology and psychiatry, 52 (6), 647-660 Rutter, M (2008). Genes and Behavior: Nature–Nurture Interplay Explained. Hoboken, Wiley-Blackwell Rutter, M and Uher, R (2012). Classification issues and challenges in child and adolescent psychopathology. [online]. International review of psychiatry, 24 (6), 514-529. Shakespeare T. (2006) Disability rights and wrongs. London, Routledge Shakespeare, W (1982) Hamlet. Ed. Harold Jenkins. Methuen, London Ward, T, Beech, A (2006). An integrated theory of sexual offending. [online]. Aggression and violent behavior, 11 (1), 44-63. Žižek S. (2013) The Pervert‘s guide to ideology [DVD] ZKM (2005) Center for Art and Media, Karlsruhe: IconoClash [online] Last accessed 30 April 2016, available at http://hosting.zkm.de/icon/stories/storyReader$3
The first challenge in introducing Actor-Network Theory (ANT) lies in its very objective: moving beyond and away from simplistic, ready-made frameworks and deterministic concepts, as it attempts to capture complexities and interrelatedness: a world that is in motion. Secondly, ANT has not yet been included in the popular textbooks as a qualitative research method. Thirdly, it has hardly been applied to my field of research interest, to hidden cognitive disabilities studies. Yet, these were the key reasons while I was so keen to explore it. This short essay does not intend to provide an in-depth explanation of ANT. Instead, it is the kind of first rendezvous, where you rather feel it than know it and consider whether it could develop into a deeper and more meaningful relationship in the future. What is Actor-Network Theory In order to place Actor-Network Theory in the history of social sciences research, one could say that it started with a study of a French biomedical laboratory in 1979 by Latour and Woolgar: Laboratory Life. The Social Construction of a Scientific Fact. The name, actor-network theory, was devised by Callon around 1982, and it first appeared in the literature in 1986 in an article by Callon, Law and Rip. ANT is attributed to Michel Callon (1986), Bruno Latour (1988) and John Law (1986). ANT, like all theories and methods were influenced by various thinkers and concepts including the work of Tarde, Garfinkel, Kuhn, Foucault; as well as ethnomethodology, symbolic interactionism, relativism or feminism. Most qualitative methods emphasise the importance of axioms that are the propositions of research paradigms. However, Law (1992) argues that ANT is not a theory, and there are no predefined axioms. ANT, also called the sociology of translation, is an approach, a toolkit and a method of analysis. ANT is the practice of material semiotics: the study of relations between elements and concepts. Behind the Name The name itself requires some explanations as it does not reflect the openness, uncertainty and diversity that ANT aims to offer. Law and Hassard (1999) highlighted that the process of labelling itself means turning a motion-picture into a still image. Actor-Network with its hyphen is intentionally oxymoronic representing a centred Actor and a decentred Network. However, Actor and Network are not an alternate version of Agency and Society or Agent and Structure dualism. They are two sides of the same phenomenon. The Network should not be conceptualised like the world wide web, where information is readily available without any transformation; and the Actors are not only people: they are objects, subjects, humans, machines, ideas, organisations, inequalities and places. Although ANT is not a fixed and single theory, it is neither a collection of some ad-hoc ideas or practices. It aims to operate in and capture the complexities of tensions: nature and culture, macro and micro, local and global. However, perhaps, as a result of this fluidity, ANT that started from science and technology studies has since been applied to numerous other disciplines preserving its main characteristics but transforming it into something new every time whilst staying partially connected. ANT can be best described as it “treats everything in the social and natural worlds as a continuously generated effect of the webs of relations within which they are located” (Law 2007 p.2). Key Characteristics of Actor-Network Theory The main components of ANT as expressed by Law (2005) 1) semiotic relationality – it is the network itself whose elements will shape one another; 2) heterogeneity – there are various actors, human and non-human; 3) materiality – numerous elements are present; 4) movement – all elements play their part moment by moment; 5) effects – power or politics are the function of network configuration and the creation of fixed movements; 6) space and scale – networks extend themselves and translate distant actors. ANT argues that in traditional social sciences an artefact exists, a constant back and forth movement between the micro, the face-to-face interaction, and the macro, the elements that are already in place: structure, norms, culture, context. ANT argues that the social is not made of agency and structure, local interactions and hidden forces; every dualism is an effect that should not be overcome but ignored. It treats the natural and the social, the human and the non-human equivalent, as for ANT the social is the movement itself, a circulating entity: not what an actor does, but what provides actants with their actions, subjectivity, intentionality and morality. Entities have no inherent existence, but they acquire attributes as a result of their relations with other entities. And when people connect to this circulating entity, they are partially equipped with consciousness, subjectivity, and actoriality. ANT questions the inherent existence of: out there nature, in there psychology, down there politics and up there theology. One of the strengths of ANT is the absence of a fixed theory of the actors together with the role attributed to non-humans in the description of an actions (Law 2007). Rendering the Invisible Visible (see story for illustration below in another blog) Moser and Law (1999) offered an example of the close links between materiality of dis/ability and the continuities and discontinuities of subjectivity. In the case of physical disabilities, it was demonstrated how objects could enable dis/abled people. But what happens if someone has a hidden cognitive disability? Intellectual disability or autism? The aim of my inquiry is to attempt to illustrate that objects do not only en-able and re-able but also dis-able. Moreover, objects can pro-able but preventing one from becoming dis/abled. Furthermore, objects and ANT can render the invisible visible. Problems and Approaches FIRST STEPS Law (2004 p.7) expressed that ANT starts the enquiry from “the world as an unformed but generative flux of forces and relations that work to produce particular realities”. Therefore, ANT works with uncertainties and controversies about who and what is acting instead of the determination of action by society, the calculative abilities of individuals or the power of the unconscious (Latour 2005). It will be the work of the actants themselves – someone with a disability, a company, a piece of paper, a policy – that close controversies and settle uncertainties producing empirical traces that can be documented. Therefore, ANT would first ask, how hidden cognitive disabilities present themselves in a particular situation without first creating boxes of a predefined shape, colour and size. PRACTICAL CONSIDERATIONS Most research method before we even start our study will define many key elements: the participants, the tools and the nature of the setting. ANT, on the other hand, will not predefine or limit the number of actors that not only include humans but non-humans. Certain practical issues when doing ANT research will be shared with most research methods: who are the gatekeepers, how we can get access to data, the effect of the researcher’s gender, age, race, dialect/accent and all sorts of practical considerations. UNCERTAINTIES AND CONTROVERSIES The nature of groups – how actors given an identity ANT does not disregard the role of order, rigor and pattern but it believes they are created by the actors and not be by the researcher. Instead of deciding in advance which group and level of analysis to focus on, ANT will follow the actors. Groups are constantly formed and dismantled, and these activities leave behind many traces that can be used as data. ANT works with the many shifting frames of reference instead of sticking to a fixed one. When someone with hidden disabilities takes the bus and have a journey, all sorts of frames will be constructed, deconstructed and reconstructed. Between the individual, the money, the driver, the machine and the ticket; between the individual, the seat, the music, the passengers and the racing landscapes. During a short journey between two stops, many groups are made and remade, activities produced. ANT does not believe that the forces are already out there that forms these groups. That society already exists, so our role is to discover the perspectives. Most methods start with assumptions: hidden cognitive disabilities are already there with all the participants, rules and norms. We can explore what a person with a disability thinks about his/her condition, and how he/she will act based on this belief. ANT has a different approach: it is the formation itself that is the key, as there exists no society or fixed processes to keep all those groups together. In every action, ANT will look for the intermediaries that transport without transformation and for mediators that transform, translate, distort and modify. The machine on the bus is usually just a machine, an intermediary that makes the journey possible. You show your card, it reads it and you travel. If you know how it works. But the moment someone with a hidden disability does not know how to use the machine, the machine becomes a mediator. And it changes everything. It follows that for ANT there is no preferred type of aggregates but an endless number of mediators that can be turned into intermediaries that may mobilise more mediators. Intermediaries add predictability to the setting while mediators can suddenly change things in unexpected ways. The nature of actions – various actors intervene and displace the original goal ANT argues that actions are not under full control, but they are the result of a combination of numerous surprising sets of elements; therefore, the social has to be demonstrated each time, it can never be simply assumed. We are never alone in an event. Many times when a situation breaks down – an individual gets on the bus, s/he can’t use the machine, the driver loses its patience, the individual becomes more and more agitated – we tend to jump to predefined concepts, place the event into the wider social context and use a social force or a medical approach to explain the situation. They will not think of the machine, the role of the pass or the piece of paper called ticket. They will not explore and consider the various associations. They will jump into a theory, the social or medical model of disability, for example. They will filter out many elements, particularly the non-human entities and use established categories instead. Causation is not necessarily lawful in social life; not in a way at least that most methods would love to find. The nature of objects – type of agencies remain wide open ANT is an object-oriented approach, as it believes humans themselves are object oriented. ANT does not claim that objects do things instead of human actors, but it argues that social phenomenon cannot be understood without exploring all the participating elements. ANT is probably right when it highlights that in our example hardly any of the action was a direct human-to-human connection. Objects played a key role. Between the individual and the driver there is the machine, the money, the ticket, the bus, the language, etc. Therefore, ANT places humans and non-humans at the same level within these complex interrelationships. Many methods still treat objects as material artefacts, yet, they should be analysed in the context. On the other hand, we probably all agree that most social phenomena are impossible without objects. For most people the strip of white paper and the number on it that comes out from the machine on the bus is nothing else but a material artefact. A ticket. Is it? The nature of facts – the links of natural sciences with the rest of society Specifically, natural sciences and quantitative methods keen to prove that there exists sets of law and order. ANT argues that facts and reality are constructed, and non-human elements have a major role in the process. ANT aims to dissolve the social and the natural dualism, which has a particular reference to the studies of hidden disabilities. Moreover, ANT does not support the multiple perspectives of the same nature nor the unification of perspectives provided by nature. When there is a mismatch between a getting to be very impatient bus driver and a getting to be very agitated individual with hidden disabilities, what does really happen? Do the bus driver and the individual have a different perspective on the situation? Is it a question of different biological configurations? Or is it possible that they have started the interaction from two different realities that eventually overlapped through the medium of the stripe of white paper and the number on it? You might see it now why ANT suggests that the mismatch has not been already arranged by nature e.g. genetics and brain anomalies, neither it has been created by a mysterious social context e.g. discrimination and stigma. It was born in the relation and movement of various elements. Type of social studies – writing risky accounts ANT tries to establish as many connections among the many mediators as possible to create an account that is reflexive, articulated and idiosyncratic; that can capture differences and incorporate multiplicity. ANT does not aim to control and limit the elements and apply strategies and categories. WORKING WITH DATA Field diaries are the most traditional and important tools to record observations as well as analytical thoughts. Latour (2005) suggests that doing ANT all we need is four notebooks. A more traditional qualitative method will observe the interaction between the driver and the individual with a hidden disability and will collect oral accounts including naturally occurring conversations. A traditional method would decide whether the individual with the hidden disability is the source of information about himself/herself and the world he/she lives in or his/her account is a social product that can tell something about the socio-cultural processes that produced the situation. Other actors would also be used as informants; they can tell what happened and their account can be analysed in terms of perspectives they imply, discursive strategies they employ and the psychosocial dynamics they suggest. ANT will follow the network, the movement and they will record whatever is circulating in the interaction: all the aggregates, participating agencies that make actors do things, and non-human objects. ANT offers that any given interaction overflows by many elements already in place that come from other times, other spaces and other agents – the fair, the machines, the paper, the policy, the poster, the bus, the confusion, etc. ANT will move to other sites to find the sources of those ingredients but without jumping into contexts or structures, condensing all of them into one social construct, such as, “promoting independence”. ANT will highlight that such objects are crucial in producing disability that is assembled together as subject. This individual and his/her disability is not predetermined but was formed in these semiotic-material arrangements. ANT argues that as soon as all those actors are treated not as intermediaries but as mediators they render the movement, the invisible disability visible to the reader. The network enables each actor to make other actors do unexpected things through translations. Data is then the trace left behind by the moving agents. Clamps and Plug-ins in ANT ANT asks the question: how to stay in one place and follow the trace? Latour (2005) suggests a three steps process: Relocate the global to prevent jumping from interaction to context – ANT aims to reveal the long chains of actors: the connections from one local interaction to the other places, times and agencies and the mediators that transform something in every transport. ANT will resist the temptation to go global: institution, economy, inequalities. ANT will not frame in advance, as they are the actors that do the scaling, spacing, and contextualising. The aim is to bring this very framing activity into the foreground. ANT gives freedom to the research; there is no urge to move between predefined categories and concepts, suggest directions, frameworks and seek relationships across the data set. Redistribute the local to understand why interaction is such an abstraction – For ANT what happened on that bus at those moments, the interaction, had many elements; some of which coming from other places, distant materials and far away actors. We do not know the origin of all those elements, but ANT claims, it does not follow that they come from a global context, a framework, or a structure. ANT argues, if we could trace back every single actor and its associations, we found that out there reality or a hidden social force did not exist. Disability at that moment in that situation was the result of the incomprehensible complexity of the physically uncountable yet not infinite number of elements. There is no need for a concept to exist first to make sense of the event. We do not start with employing structures, rules, norms and culture. We aim to discover how the human actors perform social life and how they achieve orderly conduct. For ANT the scale is relative, and actors are not small participants inside some framework. ANT takes the argument a step further when it claims, that apart from these clamps that help to relocate the global and redistribute the local, there are also plug-ins: subjectifiers, personalisers, individualisers. Plug-ins provide the actors with the tools that are necessary to interpret the situation. Individuals do not have inherent capabilities to make sense of an event. They have to download plug-ins from constantly circulating entities in order to gain the necessary ability for a while. Plug-ins do not determine; they can simply make someone to do something. Nothing that happened on that bus is a result of some sort of outside social forces that determine the inside. There is no such thing that innate and constant subjectivity, personality, and consciousness. Connect the sites, localising the global and distributing the local together – Every time a connection is formed, a new channel is established that transports some new type of entity. What circulates inside those channels are the very acts that give something a visible dimension. The link is some form of displacement: a piece of paper, a ticket or a phone number. ANT claims, that if we want to reassemble the social, we need to explore the circulating entities. In other words, we first need to attend to the associations out of which the object was made and only after look at how it has affected the social ties. We shall not concentrate on the interaction only without paying attention to the objects. We shall not pre-select the focal point, that is most often the people and their actions. Traditional methods would approach the interaction from a different angle. Ideas emerge from the researcher’s experience in the field and from his/her preliminary analytic reflections on the data. The researcher will use concepts to make sense of the data and the literature or other sources to fit the data into some sort of framework. The researcher may turn towards conversation analysis or discourse analysis as the main feature is what people do and why with words rather than with objects. If the driver had more patience, used explicit language, different words … it would have been a completely different story. Objects have no role to play. On the other hand, if the object is not there, if the individual knows how to use it, if it is more user friendly… no such conversation and issue would have occurred. Discourse is an invaluable insight into how the driver and the individual created the situation discursively. It does not tell us how the interaction started, developed and ended. The Product An ANT account will end in a written account exploiting the use of the full repertoire of creative writing. As Latour (2005) explained, textual accounts are the social scientists’ laboratory: they are just as objective, scientific and valid. An ANT narrative traces the network, where all the actors do something. It gives no fixed framework to what is being described, as it is the work, the movement, the flow, and the changes that should be emphasised. ANT maintains that the actors tell the story, so the account needs to describe and avoid explanation. Summary Materiality, subjectivity and ability/disability cannot be separated, and that connections and movements between actants have a key role. Contemplating on some questions, we all can draw our conclusions how well the different methods can render the invisible visible. Do objects play a key role or is it all about discourse? Are events governed by hidden social forces? Do we need norms, rules, a common measure of thing to learn something about the people who live with a hidden disability and the challenges they face? Does it need a framework? Is the story missing a theory, an ‘ism’? Would it make a difference if we knew how genetics interacted with the environment? Do we have to hold responsible politics or culture to learn something new and initiate change? Would the story still hold if we carefully selected and filtered out the actors, especially the non-human elements instead of recording everything? Given the possibility of the impossible, could we follow all the actors back to their sources? The driver, the bus company, the manufacturers, the inflexibility… to trace down all the elements that played their role? That we prefer to group together and call reality and an invisible social force out there? There are many more questions that could be asked. At the end of this speed dating rather than a rendezvous with ANT I decided that Actor-Network Theory has some untapped potential to explore the world in its complexity including human’s relationships to objects and other non-human actors and to render the invisible visible. REFERENCES Callon, M. (1986). Some Elements of a Sociology of Translation: Domestication of the Scallops and the Fishermen of Saint Brieuc Bay. In J. Law (Ed.) Power, Action and Belief: a new Sociology of Knowledge? Sociological Review Monograph. London, Routledge and Kegan Paul. 32: 196-233. GREAT BRITAIN, Department of Health (2001) Valuing People. HMSO, London Latour, B. (1979) Laboratory life: the social construction of scientific facts. Beverly Hills: Sage Publications. Latour, B. (1988) The Pasteurization of France. Cambridge, Mass., Harvard University Press. LATOUR, B., (1987) Science in action: how to follow scientists and engineers through society. Milton Keynes: Open University Press. Latour B. (2007) Reassembling the social: an introduction to actor-network-theory. Oxford: Oxford University Press Law J. (2004) After method: mess in social science research. London: Routledge Law, J. (1986). “On Power and Its Tactics: a View from the Sociology of Science.” The Sociological Review34: 1-38. LAW, J. and HASSARD, J., (1999) Actor network theory and after. Malden, MA; Oxford [England]: Blackwell/Sociological Review. LAW, J., (1992) Notes on the theory of the actor-network: Ordering, strategy, and heterogeneity. Systems Practice, 5(4), pp. 379-393. LAW, J., (2009) Actor Network Theory and Material Semiotics. The New Blackwell Companion to Social Theory, Blackwell Publishing Ltd MOSER, I. and LAW, J., (1999) Good passages, bad passages. The Sociological review, 47(S1), pp. 196-219. SMALL, H., (1988) Mapping the dynamics of science and technology: Michel Callon, John Law and Arie Rip (Eds), The MacMillan Press Ltd, London, 1986, pp. 242. Scientometrics, 14(1-2), pp. 165-168.
Although it remains controversial, genetics, epigenetics and neurobiology have contributed significantly to our understanding of hidden disabilities by the discovery of numerous underlying biological processes such as genes and chromosomes anomalies, structural and functional brain deviations, epigenetic modifications or alterations in the HPA and neurotransmitter system (Goozen et al. 2007; Hyde, Shaw and Hariri 2013). As a consequence, the medical model and natural sciences aim to identify ill-health (diagnosis and label) and investigate its causes (aetiology) to predict the progression of the disorder (prognosis) and offer actions to cure or improve it (treatment) (Rogers and Pilgrims 2013). However, in most cases there is no one single cause of the disorder. This is further evidenced by the “missing heritability” phenomenon, the fact that up until today science failed to identify the gene variants that according to the medical model underline to varying degrees most hidden disabilities (Chaufan and Joseph 2013). And even if we have a single cause such as Trisomy 21, most commonly known as Down Syndrome, there are no two journeys the same. Kenny, the world’s oldest living man with Down syndrome, has recently celebrated his 76th birthday. In the 1940s, when he was born, life expectancy for people with Down Syndrome was set for 12 years that has gone up to 60 years these days. Rutter and Uher (2012) extensively discussed the challenges of the diagnostic manuals such as the adaptation of a life-span approach, incorporation of the dimensional nature of mental health disorders into a categorical system, the substantial overlap among disorders, inclusion of both scientific validity and clinical utility, duration of symptoms, a terminology that is accessible for non-medical professionals and the replacement of outmoded languages. Labelling practices also should reflect the most important aspects of a developmental perspective that is holism (a behaviour is an integral part of a complex context) (Sroufe and Rutter 1984) that incorporates various factors from diverse disciplines (genetics, constitutional, psychological, environmental, sociological) (Cicchetti 1984), an understanding of pathology in view of normal functioning (Sroufe 1991) while taking into account continuity, change and discontinuity (Rutter 1986) in consideration that development is lawful (Sroufe and Rutter 1984), but in a probabilistic not deterministic fashion (Rutter 2010, Sroufe et al. 2010). And while one could argue that people should not be labelled, many times non-labelling means that people’s vulnerabilities with respect to a particular society’s expectations are not acknowledged at the earliest possible time that could lead to an escalation of behaviour and missed opportunities, in extreme cases to a failed life. Especially in modernity, in our competitive, performance-obsessed society. But how can we ensure that labels will act as a compass giving us the opportunity to create a map rather than as a map already busy with predefined trails? Latour (1993) highlights that phenomenon is entrapped between subject-objects, societies-natures, locals-globals. He argues that once nature and society are united, all sorts of questions can be asked again: are hidden disabilities rooted in genetics or can be affected by other unknown processes? How are psychiatrists going to account for the misdiagnosis? How is the government going to support these people just when institutions and specialist services were closed down? Are authenticity and individual differences supported by the scientific facts? Nature and society do not explain what hidden disabilities are, but the opposite; hidden disabilities could redefine what nature and what society may be. At the extremes, there is nothing except the purified entities – Nature and Society, Globalism and Localism -, and in the middle, where nothing is supposed to be happening, there is almost everything (Latour 1993). Labels like mad, lunatic, idiot or frantic have been used since Medieval times to describe hidden disabilities. Some of these terms such as idiocy were used until 1968, the 8th edition of the International Classification of Diseases (ICD) that changed it to mental retardation that is still the official medical terminology for intellectual disability. Baudrillard argues labels are necessary to show that society cares about us, want to solve our problems and reduce our anxieties; they offer a sense of freedom and identity. However, they are also used to mask real inequalities. He further argues that labels such as disabled are often used to generate alternative notions of abled because the system sells us the signs of opposition such as exclusion as eagerly as it sells us the signs of conformity such as inclusion to maintain its power. A range of predefined labels is created by the Code for hidden disabilities to be positioned within the identity/difference binary opposition. Madness is used many times to maintain the idea that modern life is not mad. As long as some are labelled with “real” and “objective madness”, we can relax; we are normal.
Labelling in the different disciplines
Autism and the diagnostic description of most conditions are based on the observation of people who display set behaviours. In terms of autism, these consisted of mostly very young children, mainly boys and to some degree their families. All the observations, tests and case studies then were turned into a couple of pages long descriptions that were then presented as a couple of sentences in the diagnostic manuals. Intellectual disability and most mental health disorders followed a similar path. The media and Hollywood “image creators” then produce autism, learning disability and mental health disorders; some of the most well-known are Rain Man (1988), an American drama about an autistic savant, Raymond who has strict routines, superb recall and mental calculating abilities, but shows little emotions except when in distress. Mercury Rising (1998), an American political thriller in which a nine-year-old boy with autism cracks a top secret military code and therefore is haunted by the government assassins. Forrest Gump (1994), another American film about a man with lower intelligence level yet with an amazing ability to run. Beautiful Mind (2001) portrays Nash and his battles as he develops paranoid schizophrenia displaying his amazing talent as well as the disorder’s burden on his wife and friends. And the contemporary TV series that probably have never been based on any model, and might have more connection with other images rather than with the origin. Dr. Spencer Reid is a 24 years old character of the Criminal Minds, a genius with an IQ of 187, three BAs and three PhDs: “he is an eccentric genius, with hints of schizophrenia and minor autism, Asperger’s Syndrome.” Perception is an American crime series starring Dr. Daniel Pierce, a schizophrenic neuropsychiatrist who assists the FBI on some of their most complex cases using his hallucinations. Bones is based on forensic anthropology and the main character, Temperance Brennan is portrayed as an Aspie (Asperger’s syndrome): Her lack of social skills, specifically her saying, “I don’t know what that means,” whenever popular culture is referenced, gives most of the humour of the film. And the contemporary updates of the well-known and world famous character of Sherlock Holmes from Sir Arthur Conan Doyle: Sherlock, the British-American version and Elementary, the American series. The former key character described as “cold, techie, slightly Aspergerish”, while the latter is “slightly autistic, perhaps a bit sociopathic”. And Autism becomes Dustin Hoffman, learning disability Tom Hanks, whilst schizophrenia Russell Crowe. Dr Reid will be determined by Dr Brennan based on Raymond. Neither Raymond nor Sherlock have never existed. Autism will be bypassed by the play of the signifiers “techy”, “savant”, “geek” and “socially awkward”. Hence, Baudrillard argues, that the representation tends to be replaced by simulation where signifiers lose their connection with the signified as meaning is generated by relations between signifiers rather than in our reflective or inner dialectical thought processes. This will have many consequences related to stigma, stereotypes, identity problems, and labelling practices. The directors of Bone said: “Now that Bones is an established hit, Hanson has thought about a storyline for next season where Brennan explores the idea that she has Asperger’s. But he shares the concern of the Big Bang writers. We’d have to get it absolutely right. If you don’t get it right, you’re damaging people.” But can you get it right? “If you’ve met one person with autism, you’ve met one person with autism,” Dr. Stephen Shore. But the consequences are subtler and can be devastating when it comes in the disguise of stigma and identity. Among others, all these films feature people with hidden disabilities together with some savant skills; high IQ, outstanding memory, superior reading speed or being a medium. It sends out a message that you are not good enough to be seen as normal, but you are not good enough to be disabled either unless you have some special skills. It confuses people and it becomes a great burden on the individuals and their families who find it difficult to accept their disabilities, especially if they have no special skills: “but at least you are special, so I wish” – heard many times. We like your oddness as long as you have some superior skills in exchange. So what happens when someone is neither funny nor special but an ordinary “autistic” or “schizophrenic” or live happily with a lower IQ? Am I good enough to be loved and accepted? Baudrillard explained that various differences are allowed as long as it is prescribed by the Code. And here comes the labels. Do we need them to support or to correct or to create? “This manipulation tells us precisely what the future human being will be. He will be a corrected, rectified human. He will be from the outset what he should have been ideally. He will never, therefore, become what he is. He won’t even be alienated any longer, since he will be modified pre-existentially, for better or for worse” (Baudrillard 2005 p29).
“Computers will overtake humans with AI at some within the next 100 years. When that happens, we need to make sure the computers have goals aligned with ours.” – said Stephen Hawking. I say we do not have to wait for this. Machines and computers have already overtaken humans and their autonomous, rational thinking. And maybe it aligned with the system but not with us, humans. And why we need much more research around the ethical and practical use of machines to ensure what Hawking has rightly highlighted: “machines have goals aligned with ours.” To put the story into perspective, I need to state here some medical terminology and “standards of measurement”. Heart rate: Your heart rate is the number of times your heart beats per minute. Normal heart rate varies from person to person. The agreed normal range is 60-100. Blood pressure: When your heart beats, it pumps blood around the body and as the blood moves, it pushes against the sides of the blood vessels. The strength of this pushing is the blood pressure. The first (top) number is the systolic blood pressure, the highest level the blood pressure reaches when the heart beats. The second (bottom) number is the diastolic blood pressure, the lowest level the blood pressure reaches as the heart relaxes between beats. Agreed normal range 120/80. The top should be between 100-140, and the bottom should not go above 90/100. If the top is over 140 you have a so called high blood pressure that requires treatment. I have a historically low blood pressure; I am glad when it reads something like this 110/70. My blood pressure was last taken two days before this incidence in a very stressed and highly agitated mood. It read as follow: 112 over 76, heart rate 75. Regardless of being after exercise, smoking and coffees or anything else you not supposed to do before readings, I never in my life got a reading above 120. Certainly not above 125. I have to visit my GP ever so often to take my blood pressure. Otherwise, I do not get my prescription. But, to save time and money we invented healthcare monitors. Great invention. It takes your height, weight and blood pressure. It even talks to you and gives you a ticket at the end. And it sends your information to the computer, to your file for the doctor to approve it. Awesome. Modern. Practical. Or maybe not always? These tools should support us, humans. But what happens when the machines overtake? I naively walked into the room. Read the instructions, and removed my shoes, coat and fitness watch. The machine asked a few information to identify me. Perfect. It took my height, my weight and my blood pressure. I was not very comfortable as the cuff did not embrace my tiny wrist very well. After a few seconds, I was awarded my blood pressure: 175/73 Heart rate: 50. Whoa! That is something. My blood pressure is through the roof, and my heart is hardly beating. I stormed to the receptionist. “This machine is not working. Have a look at the paper. Do you have a traditional one I could use?” “You need to relax and sit down for a few minutes. Then you can take it again. You must be excited, and your blood pressure is high.” “I have a heart rate of 50! Have I just developed an athlete heart, too?” “All I can say that if the doctor sees this, you will never get your medication. You need to relax.” “I know. It is wrong; I need a traditional machine. I can prove it to you.” “We do not have one.” No success. I went back, and as opposed to the previous reading when I was absolutely relaxed, this time I was really agitated. And here comes the second reading. Blood pressure 143/71 Heart rate: 122 Amazing. As a result of stress, my blood pressure has just dropped by 20%, and my heart rate has just gone up by 145%. Being very confident in my argument this time, I rushed back to the receptionist. “It is not working. Look. These numbers are complete nonsense. They are moving in the opposite direction anyway.” “You see, your blood pressure has dropped a bit, but your heart is too high this time.” “Yes, because it does not measure me. I have a small wrist.” “You must be too stressed. You need to relax.” Within five minutes I was transformed from an individual to a powerless patient who has no right what so ever to know her own body, experiences and how the method works. Few minutes argument followed, and I managed to book an appointment with the nurse. “Patient wants a revision of her blood pressure reading.” And here comes the era of the machines, and the negotiation of my blood pressure. “These readings are wrong. I don’t want them on my file. Can you take them off?” “I can’t say that the machine is wrong, it was calibrated.” “But I will take your blood pressure.” “You need to take them off, make then a note.” “We can’t do this.” “Ok, so do you have a digital one? Can I use it?” “No, I only use the manual one. The automatic one is not reliable.” Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait. Is this a flaw in thinking or is it just me? You said the machine out there was good, and you could not question its reliability because it was CALIBRATED, but you would not use any automatic blood pressure machine because they were unreliable. And what? We, humans, can’t take off a measurement or leave a note because THE MACHINE said it? Something is wrong here. But the best is about to come. There are various types of manual blood pressure machines. The one with a big measuring log, the mercury sphygmomanometer where you, the patient can clearly see the mercury going up and down, hesitating for a second or two, then going further down. And the one, the nurse used. A tiny round device, a bit bigger than a watch yet it can still comfortably sit in her palm. In short, you, the patient has no idea what is happening, how far she pumps it up or at which point the dial starts bouncing a bit up and down. “You need to relax; you are wind-up.” “Yes, I am. And actually, it is good, because at least I have the chance to have a blood pressure around 120. I suffer from low blood pressure. You cannot normally measure one around 120. ” “It can change in a minute. I will show you.” And she did. The following episodes lasted less than a minute. I was constantly talking, that you not supposed to do, and she managed to take my blood pressure three times on the same arm within less than a minute, that again you can’t really do. Trust me; I am a nurse. Good evening everybody we have for auction Anita’s blood pressure today. The nurse pumped up the cuff, and within second she exclaimed: “142 over 73!” Looking at Anita whether she will accept the offer. The first offer is 142 over 73. It is an excellent one; I start the bidding with 142 over 73. Anita soon replied with a monotone and indifferent voice, not even looking up. “No, it is too high. My blood pressure is never above 120”. She pumps up the cuff again, getting more and more excited; after a second or two comes the next offer: “134 over 72.” We have 134 over 72 in the room. Looking at Anita again whether she takes this offer. 134 over 72 for once, and… Anita is shaking her head. “No, it is still too high. I have a low blood pressure.” The nurse quickly moves on. She pumps up the blood pressure again, and this time not even after a second declared an offer: “123 over 71.” Ladies and gentleman. Anita blood pressure is 123 over 71. I said 123 over 71. It is 123 over 71 once. Last chance, 123 over 71, twice. Anita looked up at her at this point and said “Fine. Deal. I take it”. Hammer then. SOLD. “I am going to record this last one on your file, 123 over 71”. And here it comes, I negotiated my blood pressure down from 175 over 73 to 123 over 71. “I told you I would show that your blood pressure changed all the time.” “Yes, I know what you showed me. I am a nurse”. If you wondered, no, she has never measured my heart rate. Why would she,? We both had a very different reality from the one the machine owned. We agreed. The machine did not. This time the machine indeed transformed, and not only transported the message. The machine turned me from a healthy and fit person to someone who needs urgent care. My readings remain on my file because the calibration of a machine is superior to humans’ ability to analyse, question and reason. And the creative yet indoctrinated healthcare professional was put in a position where she had to negotiate my blood pressure so we all could get what we needed and wanted. The right thing. We both knew this from the very beginning. Patient: the prescription as soon as possible and not coming back for as long as possible Nurse: get out this patient as soon as possible with a prescription for as long as possible This is not only questionable but very dangerous if we give power to machines over human’s ability not only to produce the results but to work with those results that machines produce. Professionals should be trained and given the right to think, analyse and question. Even if it is a CALIBRATED machine. It certainly was not calibrated on my tiny wrist that in fact, statistically, biologically and socially abnormal. In short, my wrist is not only tiny (a size of an average 5-6 years old child, well under 6 inch, and yes I researched it) but it has also acquired something that most people do not possess. It lives in harmony with a tiny piece of glass inside. A memory of one of my childhood adventures. I have many such memories. Is it possible that it made a difference? Probably not. But we will never know. Who we are, humans, intuitive, thinking and mortal souls to question the perfection of machines.
This account is based on a true story from a fictitious diary of a young adult with autism, narrated by Maya. Maya had an appointment at 10.00 at this stage for a consultation. Apparently, for patient safety reasons, consultation is now mandatory before using any contraceptives. Maya was suggested to use the IUS method (intrauterine system) as it is a long-term solution, so she is not required to remember to take a pill every morning. Maya arrived like anybody else. No signs of being “disabled” or even being different. Maya was immediately given a form that she completed, and after a bit of a hesitation, she disclosed her long-term condition: Asperger/Autism. The contact between the receptionist and Maya was formed by a photocopied questionnaire. Although, this form was designed to communicate it soon landed in a folder ready for the professional to be collected. No questions were asked at this stage about reasonable adjustments, as no one read the form and the messages it conveyed. 15 minutes have passed, and Maya started becoming agitated. Maya always arrives on time. Maya as usual prepared mentally. Appointment at 10.00am, 20 minutes consultation, asking those questions, in and out within 30 minutes, as she has another appointment at 12.00pm. But no information was given, nobody talked to her. She was left waiting in a small and packed waiting room with constant phone calls, people coming and going, bright lights, and funny smells. Being in a woman clinic, babies were around. Maya started displaying signs of distress, so she went to the receptionist. She found out that actually someone else was waiting too, and the first patient was still in the treatment room. They did not know when they would finish the consultation or how long Maya had to wait, leaving her in an uncertain and unstructured position. Maya slowly but surely started to lose it. She was walking up and down although the place only allowed her to make three steps in one direction then the other between the chairs, the patients, and the staff. Hands crossed over her body, frequent muttering under her breath, and a high level of agitation accompanied her movements. And Maya autism began to form. Maya at this stage was waiting over 30 minutes, and she experienced sensory overload. She could not take in anymore the occasional baby screaming, the constant noise, and the flickering light. Still, nobody talked to her, checked her paper or gave her any information what was happening. 10:40 and still nothing. They could not disturb the previous consultation, and nobody else was available said the receptionist. At this point the other woman who had an appointment for 9:30 filed a complaint and left. 10:45 and finally the professional arrived. “What happened to patient number 3?” “Where is patient number 3?” The professional quickly learnt that patient number 3 left. Then she turned to Maya: “Good news, you can come in, the other patient left”. Maya burst out at this stage. “Good news!? You are 45 minutes late!” And then it started, or rather continued what Maya could not have expected. Her mental preparation left her with no suitable scenarios or scripts. The professional did not have a look at her form either; at this point, it was part of a pile of papers comfortably sitting on the professional desk. She did not know that Maya was autistic. The form did not reach its aim. It did not translate the messsage, but transported. From the receptionist to Maya then to the folder and eventually to a desk. Maya probably became an annoying patient in the eyes of the professional. Like a well-trained professional, resembling a robot, she turned to the computer and started asking all sorts of questions starting with her date of birth and name that were already in the form obviously. No contact with Maya, just with the computer. “It is all on my file with my GP, I really have to tell you my whole life?” “We do not have the data from your GP, we have to take the whole history at your first visit.” “You must be joking.” She was not. For another 40 minutes, she was asking questions. Maya occasionally exploded when the professional obviously did not listen to her or asked some ridiculous things, at least for Maya. “I need to measure your height.” “It is 165 cm. It has been exactly the same for the past 20 years.” There was no conversation, there was no interview. There was an interrogation. “Do you want to do this, or not!?” “No, I don’t, can I just sign the form?” No, you can’t it is in the patient best interest. At one point the professional said they offered cervical screening to all woman. “Would you like one?” “I had it 8 weeks ago, and I have just received the letter, it is negative. No, I do not need one.” Notes: “Patient refused.” “I haven’t refused it! I have just done one! We need to have one in every three years. Would you like to see the letter?” A few more exchange of words followed and the professional eventually agreed to extend her notes: “because it was done two months ago.” Some of her questions were so patronising that Maya did not even know what to say but wanted to scream. “So, was it negative, or have you received any treatment? “It was negative, I said I had the letter.” “You know, any treatment down below.” (audible: That’s ridiculous. She is a xxxxxxxx. I want to get out. Maya need to get out. Get out. Out. Now. Maya need to get out. Maya need to get out. Maya need to get out. Maya…) Maya completely shut off, the interrogation continues. Difficult questions, page after page, hardly possible for someone with autism to handle: your medical history, your sexual life, your family history, your sexual preferences, whether you had any pregnancy or termination, whether you had any surgery. The professional here again quickly added that the latter involved breast enlargement as well as breast reduction. By this time Maya zoned out completely, and could not pay attention to anything else but to one thing: to get out as soon as possible. After 45 minutes the professional eventually arrived to the point. The consultation. You think. The professional first demonstrated the device using a plastic model then she read out word by word the pre-printed risks and side effects. Everything that can be found online. She even offered a leaflet. A personalised method based on your needs: computer, forms, blood-pressure machine, complex and indifferent questions, a plastic womb and the pen were designed to establish a connection between Maya and the professional. There was no consultation. There was no analysis of the data given. There was no conversation. There was no compassion. There was no individualised assessment. There were objects and walls. Between them. The computer system did not analyse Maya answers. How could it? Most answers were free texts.The professional did not analyse Maya answers either. How could she? In her given role and within the allocated timeframe it is simply not possible. So what was the point of this 45 minutes consultation? After answering all these questions all she wanted, the professional is Maya to sign the consent form, so if anything goes wrong, it will be Maya fault. Then they will analyse the questions. Maya has indicated side-effects with previous methods. No comment on how the new method will affect her. Maya has indicated concerns. No comment on what to do with those anxieties. Maya has indicated risks. No comment on whether these risks could be present with the new method. All these information were swallowed by a computer. The professional was focusing on telling the pre-printed risks and on signing the form. Can she just sign the form then? The consultation did not only cause great distress to Maya but wasted the precious time and money of both parties. Unless we apply a method of analysis should we collected data? Unless we listen and read people answers and take them into account, should we ask those questions? Unless we provide people with disabilities with reasonable adjustments, should we ask them to disclose it? But there is something else that happened there. There were exactly 8 risks listed on the consent form. One sounded more terrible than the other. Citing one after the other the professional arrived to the following one: “it sometimes happens that when they place the device inside you it can make a hole on your womb. You might do not feel it. The professional might do not notice it. But it can make a whole on your womb. You might need to go to a hospital. You might need an operation”. People with autism are often visual. At this point, listening one possible complication after the other, without any reassurance, without giving Maya the chance to share her fears, Maya could not take it in any longer. Her sensory overload already made her vulnerable, then the endless verbal apathetic questions, the patronising comments and now the pictures. She visualised every one of them so far, and this one finally hit her. First time throughout the consultation the professional noticed that something had changed, Maya facial expression perhaps, her look or her body posture. Questions? No. Reassurance? No. Assumptions? Yes. At this point the professional started repeating the same thing again and again: “we might puncture your womb”, “it is possible that during the process we will make a hole inside your womb”. Waiting for some form of a reaction. Autistic people are not only visual, but they have a tendency to catastrophize things as well as the tendency to become fixated with certain images, and thoughts that will keep on repeating themselves in their head. At this point Maya said, she was going, she signed the form and left the room with this picture and sentence running in her head over and over again. And a copy of the consent form to register the bond. There were so many opportunities to get it right. There were so many small adjustments they could make. If just when the professional saw a change on her face, if just at this moment she asked a question instead of making assumptions. Just one question, just one gesture: “Are you alright?” “Do you have any question?” “Do you have any concern?” Anything to show that you listen, anything to show that you care, anything to make Maya feel like an equal partner. Or even better; like a vulnerable and frightened patient. Anything but repeating the same thing again and again. And if you do not know what is happening, or what to ask then say it: “I am not sure … Can I…? Would you…?” And if you ask the question why Maya did not say anything, why she did not initiate it, the answer is because she is autistic. Autistic people often have reduced self-preservation skills. They are vulnerable. They need the support. They disclose their disabilities. For a reason. How she supposed to make decisions whether she wants this method or not? Autistic people rarely make decisions on the spot. They need time. They need to process, to analyse. They have questions. And maybe another one. And when something goes wrong, who is there for Maya to process what happened? Who is there for them? Parents? If you are lucky enough to have a parent or have one you can talk to. Boyfriend, husband? Yes, apart from the fact that a large number of people with autism is single. A close friend? Yes, if you do not happen to be autistic because the chances are high that you do not have such a close friend. A mentor? A psychologist? A carer? Well, let’s hope they have someone because an experience like this can start a cascade of events, and potentially put an autistic people into misery and depression not only for long hours but for days. Will she ever try this procedure? Probably not. Did she have a “choice?” No, she did not have a choice. Could she make an “informed decisions”? Certainly, not. Whatever these things mean. Was Maya disabled when she show up at the appointment? No, she was not. She was a capable and independent individual like anyone else. Someone, who holds a job, who drives a car, who enjoys lots of things in life, just like anyone else. Was Maya a person with Autism when she entered the room? No, but Maya comes with some specificities. Specificities that can be grouped together under the name autism, in theory, to support her and others better. Her autism started to form when she arrived at the clinic, and for 45 minutes nobody talked to her, but she was left in a small room where slowly all the things that flow in the network overwhelmed her: the light, the opening and closing doors, the screaming babies, the phone calls, the size of the space, her growing anxiety, her inflexible mind. Yet she was still holding on. By the time the consultation finished, the combination of the elements had reached a constellation that made her autism, and indeed made her feeling and being disabled. The professional, the forms, the bright light in the room, the voice, the tone, the ignorance, the verbal processing of information, the visual aids, the computer, the time pressure, her rigid thinking, etc. The moment she left the room, her autism started to ease. And although this particular image stayed with her for long hours and days, leaving her alone in a dark and horrifying space, the moment she started driving her car, the music, the solitude and the shelter of her car unmade her autism. She looked and behaved again like anyone else. At least for the untrained eyes. Until the next particular context arrived where the elements interacted again in a way that remade her autism. Was Maya disabled all day? No. Is she an individual with Autism? No. Autism is not a fixed thing. She is autistic, she comes with a user guide. The problem is that this guide is not a pre-printed booklet, with some straightforward flow charts. But a guide that needs to be tailored-made every time. There are more and less predictable elements, but the number and the combination of factors are vast and flexible. Maya’s autism is not a thing. It is made, unmade and remade constantly in particular contexts. Reasonable adjustments could have helped. However, no set rules for actions and communication exist. Compassion, cooperation and honesty would be a good starting point. Autistic people do not need reasonable adjustment because they are disabled. They are not. They need reasonable adjustment to prevent them from becoming disabled. This is another account to illustrate why materiality, subjectivity and ability/disability cannot be separated, and that connections and movements between actors that form the networks have a key role. Contemplating on some questions, we all can draw our conclusions how well the different methods can render the invisible visible. Did objects play a key role or was it all about discourse? Was the event governed by hidden social forces? Would it make a difference if we knew which genes or neurotransmitters interacted with the environment? Do we need a common measure of thing to learn something about the people who live with a hidden disability and the challenges they face? Does it need a framework? Is the story missing a theory, an ‘ism’? Would the story still hold if we carefully selected and filtered out the actors, especially the non-human elements instead of recording everything? Given the possibility of the impossible, could we follow all the actors back to their sources? Do we have to maintain that autism is sometimes an object, a social bond, and discourse? Or that it is a bit of each? And there are many other questions that could be asked. If communicaton is better, if there is no glass wall between Maya and the receptionist, if there is no noise, if the place is bigger; if there is no computer but human contact, if the form is different, if they read the form, if the risks are more accessible, if… if any one of them is altered, the story might have been a different one. I argue that Actor-Network Theory has some untapped potential to explore the world in its complexity including human’s relationships to objects and other non-human actors to render the invisible visible. It argues that our modern approaches deny hybrids, like autism, that are nature, culture and discourse, and perhaps the Crossed-out God. If we carefully pick one or the other element before we meet the hybrids, e.g. analyse autistic people’s genetic make-up or their serotonin level, the environment or specifically the light and the discourse or specifically the form all we get is one or two pieces of the puzzle. But not their complex relationships. And as all the scientists pick the pieces from a different puzzle, we miss the full picture. It does not mean that all of these are not beneficial. But they cannot be just readily applied. Every context and every patient are different, and the same patient is different in one context or the other. Actor-Network Theory argues that “every time different agents will be made visible while others will have become dormant. Therefore the presence of the social has to be demonstrated each time anew; it can never be simply postulated” (Latour 2005 p53) This story is not unique. It is happening to people with autism or learning disability all the time. You have to tell your story again and again yet you hardly get any support. People with autism especially with more severe forms and people with a learning disability have to tell their story since birth, every time, all the time. Although we invented hospital passports, emergency grab sheets, disclosure, not much help if professionals do not read them, or have the time to read them. If you ask a question or comment, then you are the “irritating patient”. If you can ask at all. Most of the time people with autism freeze, they cannot advocate for themselves. The receptionist tried to help and gave Maya a complaint form. She did leave a comment. But whether anyone will read the comment and do anything about it remains unknown. When developing forms, visual devices and consultation methods including the questions we need to ensure that they are accessible for people with autism and with other cognitive differences.
A review of Lambros Malafouris book: How things shape the mind – a theory of material engagement. It was influenced by Latour and various contemporary views on the role of objects: in other words, it explores our approach to agents other than humans. I specifically enjoy his argument on intentionality. Most of the time when we aim to understand how an object is created or how an object participates in our life, we tend to perceive objects as mere artefacts and humans as the acting agents. We, humans, have an idea, we build up a mental image, and then we act on these internal images and plans. The object is not an active agent. There are a clear dividing line, solid boundaries and separated worlds. But do we really have intentions and do we really initiate actions without a form of interaction? Is this relation unidirectional, inactive and performed? And whilst we are acting out those actions with and on an object, are they purely passive materials or are they shape and influence our actions and intentions? Put it simply: inner state – external action – produced object. Objects do not influence. Objects do not enact. Objects do not participate. No transformation, only transportation. Neither Malafouris nor Latour and other contemporary thinkers claim that objects behave as humans. They do not. But they do not exist in isolation either. They are part of every action. Whilst they offer various examples to illustrate the matter we can all think of moments when we were really engaged in creation. In those moments, you do not know where your body ends and where the object starts. Possibly the easiest way to experience this is in art. Where do the boundaries lie between idea, creativity, my movements, the brush, the colours, or the canvas? Do the tools suffer our intention or are they embodied? And if the latter is the case for art why do we assume that is it not the case in another context? Latour differentiates between objects that act as intermediaries, the ones that bring prediction and order as they do not translate, and mediators, the ones that make life unpredictable as they transform. And any object can act as an intermediary or a mediator, and they often change roles. As I explored it in an earlier blog, this has significant consequences for people living with hidden cognitive disabilities as for them these roles of the objects and non-human agents can be more confusing. Objects, simple everyday devices, in their presence, can become mediators from their well-know intermediary roles, causing disruption; or mediators that role is to transform may reduce to intermediaries causing hesitation. If we miss the role of objects in any given situation we end up with nature, nurture and discourse. And our interventions will be directed to the medical, social and linguistic. And making another step forward, this needs to be explored in light of the fact, that people with cognitive disabilities often have a special relationship with objects as well as they have a unique sensory processing. I will explore these in more details in another blog. Right now, let’s just think more freely about the role of objects. So how does this causation looks like the other way round? The object – drives the action – that shapes the mind. We tend to have a one-way and linear thinking: from mind/human to object/world. Yet contemporary thinkers argue that often the clear division between the mental and the physical disappears as the activity is inseparable from our intentions. Attributing “actantiality” to objects and non-human actors are not inhuman, anti-human or any way against humanism. But it creates a space to approach problems from a different angle. To move away from boxes and concepts and linearity and explore the action and all the elements that influenced that action. This way we can start seeing the various issues regarding for example hidden cognitive disabilities from a different angle/s. And it does not only allow us to see phenomenon from diverse perspectives, but it extends to what actually objects do: objects change, objects reconfigure themselves, objects shape. We can now talk about various realities, not simply various viewpoints. Because it is the object that can behave differently in someone else hands, directing the activity in another way and shaping the mind to something else. This is a huge assumption: we create tests to diagnose, questionnaires to explore, flowcharts to examine based on the believe that they behave exactly the same way in every situation, every time, in most people’s hands. They are fixed, objective and reliable. Are they? Turning towards art again, the following quotes illustrate the previously discussed points well: Is it internal? “A man paints with his brains and not with his hands” Michelangelo “I dream my painting and I paint my dream” Vincent Van Gogh Is it a transference? “Real painters understand with a brush in their hand” Berthe Morisot “My hand is the extension of the thinking process – the creative process” Tadao Ando Does the artificial separation collapse at one point? “When you start a painting, it is somewhat outside you. At the conclusion, you seem to move inside the painting” Fernando Botero “I never know what I’m going to put on the canvas. The canvas paints itself. I’m just the middleman” Peter Max I would like to offer one criticism here. Malafouris offered: “Although we may well be able to construct a mental representation of anything in the world, the efficacy of material culture in the cognitive system lies primarily in the fact that it makes it possible for the mind to operate without having to construct a mental representation – that is, to think through things, in action, without the need of mental representation.” However, various research has evidenced that mental practice and rehearsal can be just as effective as physical practice providing us with empirical evidence from sport, art and learning. Moreover, imagination, the ability to create things that do not yet exist is also many time a prerequisit for scientific and artistic success. The construction of mental representations have certain benefits as opposed to relying on the material culture. And then we find the people, like autistic indivudals who live ina space where the border between the material and the imaginary disappears. I am going to finish this blog with an example from Malafouris book based on Clark and Chalmers’ famous story of Otto and Inga that is more closely related to my field of research: Both Otto and Inga wants to visit the museum, but they forget where the museum is. Inga reaches out to her memory, the biological storage system and remembers the location. Otto has Alzheimer so he consults his notebook, a physical artefact. Two different media serving the same purpose. Is the notebook an instrument, a substitute, an extension or a constitutive part? What is the difference between the two methods? The book offers various ways to approach the question. Anyone who is interested in the semiotic, relational and material contemporary approaches should read this book. A great addition to the field. And it is much more than this short blog probed. Clark and Chalmers (1998) The extended mind Latour (1993) We have never been modern Latour (2005) Reassembling the social
In a pub, chatting, drinking, snacking. A woman offers around some peanuts: – Well, actually peanuts are one of the worst things to eat. – My brother-in-law is a gastroenterologist. He never eats peanuts. It was showed that it is very bad for your stomach. -Well, I love peanuts. And he had them all with joy. What does this little dialogue teach us? That there are facts and we, uneducated and unconscious Homo Sapiens do not care? Is it a fact? I actually had a look at the literature. I am a curious person. There were hardly any reference to peanuts being bad except if you are allergic or the enzyme found in peanuts disturbs your digestion. But this is not the point. Regardless what are the “hard facts”, people follow, what, their gut feeling? Their inner voice? Or do they just simply not care? Social animals who follow their basic needs? Science and alike is so keen to deliver black and white solutions for all. Fish is good, chocolate is bad, fruit it depends. There are not many hard facts. Especially not when it comes to the so-called categories: bad and good, this and that. Obviously except some very fundamental facts. It is bad for humans to jump without a parachute. We need to rethink this sentence. It might kill you but it does not equate to bad. How could be? Bad and good are always value judgements. And the human body is not a closed system. The body, the mind and the environment are in a constant dialogue. And quite possibly not as three distinct entities with firm boundaries. Locked in a shell, allowing communication only when it is initiated. But as three penetrable, unenclosed and extended living matter whose boundaries are blurred and do not respect the confines of the visible material perimeters. The way we attend to things can completely alter their effects on us. And science is not even close to figuring out how to incorporate this phenomenon into research methodologies. This little story gave me many inspirations for my work. And many other things that happened that evening. We can’t impose facts on people. We need to enter their world and understand better how they work with information. And what else it tells us is how a meaningless social chit-chat over a glass wine for most come to be the next adventure to be explored for a different mind.
The Oxford dictionary defines reflexive as “taking account of itself or of the effect of the personality or presence of the researcher on what is being investigated”. But what does this mean in practice? Let’s assume that she is interested in researching the resilience of people who have been maltreated and the researchers herself has been abused. She has become resilient in the sense that she has overcome the adversity. She is reflexive so she will constantly reflect on her role. She has an awareness of her experience and how it might affect the research. So does it mean that she will be less or more objective, less or more impartial? Will the research become less or more credible? Let’s examine some of the options. 1. She might become more empathetic – I experienced it too, I know how you must feel and I feel what you feel. 2. She might become more objective – I know I have experienced it so I need to keep a distance. 3. She might become less empathetic – I survived and moved on so it is possible. You should stop moaning, get up and move on. 4. She might become less objective – I know what happened to you so I know how you feel. I hear what I want to hear. I hear what confirms my belief. Can we say that in version 1 and 2 the researcher was not influenced by her values but in 3 and 4 she was? Maybe. Is it possible at all to establish what is really happening? Does this reasoning work in practice? Would it make the research more objective if the same question was asked by someone who was not maltreated? Or it will be distorted too just differently. Will he make the same reflexive account? 1. He might become more empathetic – I did not experience it. I know this, but I can imagine and feel what you feel. I can listen. 2. He might become more objective – I know I did not experience it so I will not be emotionally involved. I can stay objective. 3. He might become less empathetic – I know it is terrible, but you just need to stop moaning, get up and move on. 4. He might become less objective – I do not believe that this is so complicated. I hear what I want to hear. I hear what confirms my belief. Does an objective account matter? Does an account have to be objective? What does it mean objective? What is the purpose of the research? To feel their pain, to understand the effects of the event, to find interventions, to tell their stories, to develop drugs? These all will influence what objectivity means and what method is the best to be used. And what happens when one changes her account? A story that was painful, one day becomes an invaluable lesson. A memory where she was the cause and the guilt, one day becomes the victim and the naivety. How does this change reflexivity? Change objectivity? Reflexivity is necessary, but it is never objective. And it will not necessarily make an account more objective.
On one Thursday morning, Maya, she likes her name, means water, had to change her routine. But she did not mind. She had a plan and worked out what would happen next step by step. She would walk to the bus stop, get on the bus, pay the fee with a 5-pound note to collect change so later that day when she picked up her car, she could park in the pay and display zone. … The bus slowly approached the bus stop and after the kids coming to the local school got off, she stepped onto the bus, right to the driver with the 5-pound note in her hand. – ‘To the city centre, please.’ – ‘It’s two pound thirty.’ Maya did not say a word, just kept on showing the 5-pound note. – ‘I NEED TWO POUND THIRTY’, repeated the driver with a slightly irritated tone. Maya looked somewhat confused and frozen. She did not move just kept on staring the driver. The driver was visibly losing his patience. – ‘Put it in the box then’, said the driver. Maya became disordered, as the box did not look like something that would easily swallow paper notes. As she put the money in it, it was stuck first a little, but then she pushed it further down. At the next moment, a strip of white paper started coming out of another machine, on the wall, just outside the cab. On the top of it, the numbers said £4.40. – ‘I gave you a day ticket, at least, you do not lose that much’. Few moments later Maya became distressed and eventually verbal whilst the driver just shut the door and continued with the journey. – ‘Wait, wait! What?! I did not ask for a day ticket! I said a ticket to the city centre! I do not need a day ticket! I have my car. I needed the change … Give me back the note then, I might have change with me.’ – ‘I cannot do anything now. I cannot take the money out of the box’. Maya still could see the folded note, sitting right on the top of the box. She looked upset. For long seconds, she was just watching the white strip of paper waving to her from the box with a big smile of £4.40 on it. Then Maya suddenly changed. She eventually grasped what the strip of paper and the number on it were telling her. Welcome on Board! Please, take a seat and enjoy your journey. The piece of paper has finally managed to create a space for the realities to meet. … I asked her, how she felt. She was rather inarticulate; her speech lacked emotions. – ‘I am not sure. Maya is confused. I don’t understand it. Maya is upset. She is upset. He did not explain. It is not fair’. – ‘This feeling. Everything is crumbling. You are falling to pieces.’ – ‘The bus driver, the people on the bus; they, they just do not look and feel like people at all; just some sort of homogenous background noise. No faces, no boundaries; just a hostile muttering mass. – ‘I just want to be on my own.’ Maya sat down to process, next to the window; she put her headphones on to block the inside out but let the outside in. I could hear the music. The bus quickly arrived at the city centre. Time always brakes free when you travel not on something but within. At the station words were exchanged with the driver one more time, but it changed nothing. As Maya left the bus she ensured that every unique identification would be noted; the bus number, the number of the service, the licence plate. … The customer service was not much helpful, at least, they were understanding. They gave her a large sheet of paper how to complain and Maya was diverted to the inspectors. ‘They can give you back your money’, they said to her. The inspectors were located at the back of the station, an unnoticeable, plain grey building. No signs, nothing to help you figure out what was inside the container. Maya knocked on the door, and a middle age man walked out. Maya was very agitated by that time and jumped right in the middle of the story … – ‘We do not have time to explain to every passenger how it works. We have over a 1000 passengers every day’, came the reply. ‘But look’. The inspector grabbed her hand and walked her to the first empty bus. He walked her up onto the bus. – ‘You see, on the box, it says “Exact money only”. And, there, on the poster, it says the same. We show it at two places. Exact money only’. Maya tried to explain, that if someone was new to the city, or disabled or dyslexic, it did not help. She tried to say that when you got on a bus, you immediately interacted with the driver. You would not look around whether there was anything out there for you to read. Maya kept on repeating the same questions: – ‘And what if I cannot read? Or if I am disabled?’ The inspector said nothing, went back to the dull and gloomy container and came out with a tiny piece of paper that said: customer service and a phone number. He went back and shut the door. … Maya eventually managed to reach the customer service, who recorded her complaint and promised to send her two day-tickets to ease her pain. … But Maya had to hurry now, she had a meeting to chair … It took time for Maya to digest what had happened. – ‘I do not understand what is wrong. I prepared. I always mentally prepare. I have my note, I get my change, I park my car’ … It took a long time for Maya to talk about that journey at that day … Maya was staring off into space, twirling her hair. Then, she looked back at me. – ‘This is the problem with invisible disabilities, you see. You just wish you could end this dichotomy and melt into integrity.’ – ‘But this is how you gain freedom. Another piece has just moved from the dark into the light. From now on, I am just as much in control as anybody else. Or so I believe.’ – ‘It is now visible. For you. And for me.’ – ‘If you survive the pain; as the mind sometimes prefers to escape’. The prepaid cards and the technology were introduced to safeguard, promote independence and make life easier including the life of disabled people. Yet, this very same technology just played a central role in making someone feel so handicapped. In fact, it might just have helped Maya and others to render the invisible visible. What they might mean when they say inflexible and rigid thinking patterns, problems with the theory of mind, impaired verbal information processing, and the challenges of living with a hidden disability. And why the car for people like Maya is not just simply an object. A comfortable materiality of life that takes her from A to B. Her car is one of her very extension. It does not make her able, like the wheelchair a physically disabled person. It is just the opposite. It protects her from becoming disabled. It means connecting and relating through disconnections. But it is the same sense of freedom. And if the reader paid attention, you might have noticed that this story was just a tiny fragment of a vast actor-network. If we started following one of the actors, we would learn that it has never started on that Thursday morning. It could be traced back at least to that Wednesday evening when Maya decided to leave her car behind and accept an invitation for a glass of wine…
I am research mad
The debate is ongoing between health and social. Decades and we have not moved on much in making sure, these apparent two worlds work well together. Yet, we also have a soltuion. It is called integrated practitioner.
An interdisciplinary workshop organised by Centre for the Study of Environmental Change, Centre for Gender and Women’s Studies and Centre for Science Studies, Lancaster University This workshop aims to explore recent social and cultural engagements with ontology. It brings together researchers working in diverse disciplines interested in exploring what ontological politics might mean for ‘who, how and what’ we research. We will discuss key concepts such as Ontological Multiplicity. This suggests that there are not only many ways of knowing ‘an object’ – the biosphere, sex, the autonomous – but that there are many ways of practising it, that in turn enact different realities that are variously entangled and interdependent. A further implication is Ontological Politics. As we attend to specificity and learn to see multiplicity everywhere, a crucial issue becomes which differences we want to attend to and to make. A brief summary of the event that I greatly enjoyed: Javier Lezaun ‘A non-partisan (but opinionated) look at the ontological turn’: the presentation discussed that objects-chains simultaneously exist; never certain or fixed; but multiplicity. Interpretation is delayed; dispensed through networks. Essence and existence of entities are best understood as the temporary upshot of interconnecting relations. Epistemology/ontology distinction and new materialism explored. But is ontology not a fancy word for social construction? Can we really propose one ontology? We can’t completely avoid sets of assumptions. It is a visual representation but not necessarily a system. The agency of the matter, the agential power has been presented. Matter to be treated as a practical achievement, as a quality that is also enacted in practices. The importance of the recognition of relationality. All the mediations are necessary to transform a matter a fact into a matter of concern need to be acknowledged. Key theorists noted: Eduardo Viveiros de Castro, Philippe Descola, Bruno Latour, Gilles Deleuze Prof. John Law ‘Ontological Suffocation: TEK, numbers and salmon’: emphasised the importance of empirical work as opposed to very abstract inquiries. Introduced his work on difference; different enacted realities. We might prefer one or the other, difficult to choose/abandon. Which real is better, what we mean by better and by who? The question is a practical-political matter. No general rules exist. No general things exist. My key message: suffocating alternatives. Significant differences are multiple. How can we draw the line of division? Readiness instead of punctuality. Need to be ready for the opportunity to present. A fractal world. Numbers fed into the biological model. Numbers can be easily communicated. They travel very well between places. Need to experiment with models, how we represent. How the various bundles are made: politics, representations, role of non-humans. Another key message of the presentation: We need to learn going well together in our differences. Collectively. How to nurture places through disconnections? Creating and living with otherwises/alternatives. Prof. Theo Vurdubakis ‘‘Not a Place of Honor’: Risk, Organization and the Afterlives of Signs’: dirt – matter out of place. Artwork rubbish was explored and the different enactments. People react to the artwork, participate. An STS approach. Presentation on the monument of forgetting. Box in a box in a box…various maps, each map has its consequences. What is a better enactment? How do they work in practice? Objects themselves are never troubled. Waste is waste. Waste has just appeared without having a history. History is driven. Hannah Knox ‘Thinking like a Climate? An Anthropological Approach to Biospheric Ontology’: an inconvenient truth. There was no uncertainty, but importance. Data also produces messages we do not want to hear. From language of probability to language of fact. It is not only a thing but a set of relationships. Don’t assume we have two worlds that are coming together. Thinking as climate. Reference to Latour: Gaia. Scientists as issue advocates. Don’t resolve uncertainty, describe it.
Joanne Mills: “You had to be there: examining immersion through the Lens of Minimalism”. An exciting inquiry into venue, collaboration and the influence on contemporary practice through which the changing role of the audience within the context of immersive, multi-sensory audio-visual environments from the 60s to the present day. As someone who has just started her PhD it was a great example of how to build up a project: hypothesis. key lines of inquiry, context and the fieldwork. Tara Baoth Mooney: “Caring through clothing: textile artefacts as triggers to explore personhood for people with early stage Dementia and their closest carer/family member”. An exciting project that looks at participants’ wardrobes as custodians of elements of embodied personhood by using a co-design tool and people’s own clothing. Can clothing act as a multi-sensory trigger? I really welcomed the topic. A much-neglected field. People relationship with their clothes. As a practitioner, I find it far too often that care staff does not pay attention to residents clothes. They treat them as mere objects. Necessities. Nothing more. Yet, they are probably much more than dead materials for most of us. Another important learning: getting ethical approval can take a long time. I rather start working on it. Francis Robert M: “What was lost is all we have: the literature of liminality”. The projects aims to forge a connection between post-industrial liminality of the Black County and the liminal identities or experiences the landscape gives rise to. How identity develops through the social world, and the sense of continuity. And the desire for stability. Roland Buckingham-Hsiao: “Collaborative calligraphy: an asemic writing performance”. Roland and a Taiwanese artist, an easter-western performance in Taiwan, the collective practice of calligraphy. An interesting way to perform language. Many questions have arisen around language, signs and symbols. The paradoxes and language as a social structure was presented. In my field of research, disabilities studies, it was interesting to research after the presentation that dyslexia and other forms of learning difficulties related to language present differently depending on whether a language uses symbols or letters. Apparently, if you are bilingual, let’s say English and Chinese, you can be dyslexic in one but not the other. The brain works differently with letters and calligraphies. Isi Agboaye: “Interrogating and dramatising trauma; an African post-colonialist context”. The underpinning playwriting focus of this practice-led research reflects activities within a nation in Africa. Understanding postcolonial trauma and creating interventive plays. The project suggests that plays in Nigeria should specifically dramatise trauma as underpinning for advancing decolonisation, reflecting restoration, empowerment and development. An exciting idea to insert trauma support into plays. Whilst the world trauma more often used to describe personal, highly disturbing physical and emotional experiences, I could relate to the issue presented. The use of word trauma made a link between their probably unique experiences of events and the more traditional forms of suffering helping the audience to connect with their cause.
Wolverhampton Intellectual Disability Network A fantastic day with people with learning disabilities, carers, family members, academics, providers and other organisations. Prof Val Williams and Kerrie Ford about decisions making and choice. How we can support people with LD to plan their own support, to give the support they need. I welcomed that it was highlighted no one system works for all. “I do not want to be on direct payment because I would find it hard to manage my money.” And we need to respect this. Some people can and want to learn how to do it, others do not. And it is just fine this way. We need support in one area or the other. That should never give grounds for discrimination. Some training material was presented such as how people with LD train their own PAs. Another key point: we need to understand the practice, what happens to be able to change things. A short film was presented about a person with LD and his two carers in a shop. A great insight into the discourses of people with LD and their carers. The linguistic power imbalance, the intricate manipulation and/or support in making choices, the past experiences of being controlled. An interesting conversation around mental capacity “we do not have someone always hanging around and assessing our capacity”. No, we do not. People with LD and other hidden cognitive disabilities often have. The Mental Capacity Act was introduced in 2005 and it is striking that in 2016 not only laypeople but professionals do not have an understanding what it is all about. Do you remember the starting point? “Every adult has the right to make his or her own decisions and must be assumed to have capacity to do so unless it is proved otherwise. ” Kristy Norris about orthopedic and hospital care experiences of people with LD. The importance of supporting people with LD in hospitals was discussed and the available supports including the hospital passports. People with LD who had an operation have been interviewed. How to best prepare, the information they need, how their experience can be improved. My note here: Learning Disability Liaison nurses have a key role in this, yet in many hospitals this role still only exists on paper and the professionals Lizz Raye on resilience in people with LD: a review of the literature. An important research topic into the resilience of people with LD. How much we know about people with LD who are doing fine in life? What is their secret? What helps or hinders their experience? Resilience is a complex yet fascinating topic. Looking forward the first results from the fieldwork. WIDeN researchers, Dudley Voices 4 Choice, Friends2Friends about “getting involved in the elections: the views and experiences of people with LD of the UK Election 2015. Still, a lot to do if we really want to involve people with LD in public life including the election. The provided information is rarely accessible. They discussed politician attitudes, the support available and how things could be improved. An important topic which needs more attention. Tom Denham about employment and how the council supports the employment of disabled people. Employment is everyone’s business in Wolverhampton. Great initiatives and success stories. “People with LD need to be given the chance to prove they can do it.” Various opportunities are being developed including coaching, mentoring and training. Employers need to come forward and be open to employ people with disabilities. They have a lot to offer. We need to focus on the positive aspects. Dudley Voices 4 Choice: Include me! The importance and significant positive effect of advocacy and self-advocacy. A great example what they can do and how far they can go. Rachael Mackley about online support group use and the psychological wellbeing of family carers of people with LD. “The best thing is sharing our experiences with others”. Online platform offers plenty of opportunities to support people with LD as well as their carers. They can exchange experiences, what worked or did not work, can be there for each other. It will be interesting to see as the project develops what carers say who do not use such platform. Dr Liz Tilly provided an update on the Building bridges training, able to include. The event was closed by a great performance from the Friends 2 Friends. Fun. Love. Laugh. This is how you want to end a conference. To feel proud that you are a learning disability nurse and a social worker and part of this fantastic community. Thank you everyone, it was an inspiring day.
This conference looked at the growing intersection between political philosophy and contemporary art, questions of: agency, representation after the critique of representation as violence and symbolic violence, the collective author, dramaturgy, art and use-value, art and ethics, art and the crisis of democracy, art and labour. Speakers in order: Euripides Altintzoglou, Chris Gomersall, Stewart Martin, John Roberts, Meena Dhanda, Benjamin Halligan, Angela Dimitrakaki, Alexei Penzin, Adam Kossoff, Gerald Raunig, Anna Santomauro and William Pawlett. Varied presentations from numerous disciplines were presented covering the issue of agency and crisis. The following brief based on the abstracts intends to give a flavour of the day. It started with a discussion about the avant-garde and its goal for socio-political change specifically focusing on post-capitalist avant-garde. It explored avant-garde as a driving force and methodology for change. Other presentations looked at ‘equality as comparative fairness’ in the arts incorporating empirical data on income inequalities in the arts. The next speaker explored the ‘Abstract Strike’ through examples to consider the artistic, political and philosophical configurations of these ‘artistic strikes’. It was followed by Reflections on Brechtian and Post-Brechtian Theatre and Dramaturgical Reason as his plays present the pleasures of usefulness, as a corollary of slyness. It focused on the political subject who has to make their way in the world as for Brecht abstract reason is not enough to establish a political process. The next speaker talked about Counter-ritual as Protest and Ambedkar, the architect of the Indian Constitution and an idolised hero of Dalits (a political term for the ex-Untouchables of the Indian Castes) who left behind a rich intellectual legacy. It explored the means of defiance against systematic oppression and stigmatisation of Dalits taking into account the dangers of spontaneous protests as well as the confinement within ‘respect for tradition’ and it outlined an another option, counter-ritual as a protest. Then the next paper explored and contrasted the photographer Terry Richardson’s works with Playboy regarding “Modelling Affective Labour”. Whilst his work looks more an underground hardcore pornography of yesteryear, the paper argued that his images anticipate the contemporary public recalibration of ideas of intimacy as associated with Social Media, tally with contested ideas of the sexualisation of female empowerment as associated with contested elements of Third Wave Feminism, and can be read as a contemporary phase of Antonio Negri’s theory of art and immaterial labour in their evidencing of the affective labour on the part of the photographer himself. The second half of the day started with a paper on Feminism, Art, Capitalism. It first explored what are the differences between the 1970s and now in how feminism views the problem of capitalism in relation to art. And, second, how can contemporary Marxist feminism in art history begin to make sense of this (rather fragmented and discontinuous) history of critique and its impact on art.The paper argued that working towards a possible history of feminism, art, capitalism must be seen as a necessary first step towards grasping the requirements of a contemporary critique. The next speaker attempted to provide a consistent theoretical ground for the analysis of the contemporary “always-on” capitalism whose essential feature is uninterrupted continuity of production, exchange, consumption, communication, and control, with its socio-technical infrastructure of Internet, social media, various incessant social institutions, nonstop e-commerce, etc. The concept of “continuity-form” derived from Marx’s continuity of value metamorphosis was discussed and then a parallel genealogies between philosophical and theological thinking on continuity was outlined, and it was finished with discussions of contemporary forms of life and cultural production that correspond to omnipresence of the “continuity-form”. Next, a film was projected, “How They Hate Us”. Mohammad Bakri reads Jackals and Arabs, a short story written in 1917 by Franz Kafka that reveals his ambivalence towards Zionism. The film explores Tel Aviv, a city supposedly built on sand, but one that has also conveniently reconstructed its past. Then the Concept of “Dividuum” was presented. It argues that as the philosophical, religious, and historical systems that have produced the “individual” (and its counterparts, society and community) continue to break down, the age of “dividuality” is now upon us. The speaker develops a genealogy of the concept of “dividuum” into a philosophy of dividuality as a way of addressing contemporary modes of production and forms of life. The next presenter looked at Micropolitics and Southern European Socially Engaged Art Practices in the Age of Austerity. While looking at artistic and curatorial processes that incorporate some of the methods, languages and procedures that could be identified as a social turn in contemporary art practice, this paper seeks to redefine such collective processes through the lens of the theories of micropolitics. The last speaker examined Georges Bataille’s notion of the impure ‘left’ pole of the sacred and its relationship to transgression, suffering and sacrifice. Engaging with Giorgio Agamben’s critique of Bataille’s thought on the sacred, which is based on a distinction between life that is sacrificeable, and life that can be terminated but is considered unfit for sacrifice, I suggest a number of parallels between the work of Bataille and Agamben on the sacred. The paper argues that Bataille’s approach does not neglect the political realm, nor the exploitation of the sacred in political violence and in fact offers a vision of the dismantling and ‘unworking’ of capitalist commodity relations which parallels Agamben’s project.
20th October, 2016 Univesity of Wolverhampton. Excellent talk from Prof Constantine Sandis. The presentation was motivated by the thought that the things we say and do are to be distinguished from our acts of saying and doing them. The reason for this distinction was presented and its important application to art and ethics. It aimed to show that the correct evaluation of what one does or creates may part ways with that of one’s act of doing or creating it. The art and the process of making it. The speaker argued that if the implications of this corrective for ethics and aesthetics were as significant as he claimed, then the philosophy of action should be accorded a far more prominent place within both fields than previously supposed. Issues were discussed around how we should evaluate duplications and replications. Questions were raised around the motive of the act and whether it matters or not; whether it is the consequences that matter regardless of intention. But what intention is and how we define it is a complicated question in its own right. So I ask: is intention fundamentally an internal and cognitive exercise? Or do we need an external world that linked to and consistent with the inner world for intention to be born and directed? Do we always have an intention before the action? Are objects and the acts are the results of an intention or are they part of the action of intending? I am not convinced that intention as an internal and mental phenomena can be separated from the external and material world. And these issues then leads me to contemplate on the topic and those questions related to my field, not in art but in working with people with cognitive impairments: how we can separate what one does or creates from one’s act of doing or creating it. I see these points when applied to art, and I enjoyed the examples; but I certainly need to think more re:/ what it means for example concerning mental capacity, the process of thinking; the things we do is to be distinguished from our acts of doing them. There is no doubt that the philosophy of action should have a far more prominent place within ethics, and ultimately in most inquiries we do. The connection between the mental and the material is the action. The question remains though whether these are really separated entities or they are interdependent. And once we recognise the importance of action we realise that we are never alone in carrying out an action, but we do it in relation to humans, non-humans and objects. Yet, I still struggle to see how we can evaluate an action without taking into account the result of it; or rather in certain context, perhaps in our final assessment, we need to find a way to link the evaluation of the action and the act itself.