Autism and other mysteries

I post about autism, mental health and hidden dis/abilities. Apparently, I tick the box for some of them. I am also trained to work with such conditions, and I research them. I was about to write that these are my views and not evidence-based, but how could they be anything else? Solution focused living and live methods are about experimenting and finding out what works. Primarily, for you, when, how and in what context.

Bilingual versus second language

Learning a second language as an adult with autism has many therapeutic benefits. The following excerpts explore 6 points on the difference between bilingualism and a second language.

There are a growing number of articles exploring the benefits as well as the drawbacks of being bilingual. However, before we attempt to illustrate the advantages of a second language for people with autism, we need to explore the difference between being bilingual and mastering a second language at a later stage, if this is possible at all. The Oxford Dictionary defines bilingualism as “speaking two languages fluently”. Unfortunately, it does not explicitly discuss how we should define and measure “fluency”. An issue I write a lot about.

Traditionally psychologists, as well as developmental psychiatrists, coined the term “critical period” or “critical window” not only for learning a second language but also for the acquisition of various skills. As always, in the wrong hands, such concepts easily become an inflexible and deterministic approach: once you pass a certain age, you cannot master a language or an instrument or any other skills as well as children can. And, again, as usual, the oppositions appear quickly with similar, rather rigid and fixed counterarguments that it is a false belief. Whilst contemporary ideas position themselves somewhere in between and remain fluid.

The critical window appears to exist in the sense that development has its own rhythm and laws. Adaptable and flexible but within limits and boundaries. Claiming that there is no difference between growing up in a bilingual environment since birth/young age or learning it from books as an adult is simply nonsense. In the former, it becomes second nature without even realising that you are learning it. In the latter case, it will always remain something acquired, secondary to you. Even simple expressions like “love you” will not convey exactly the same meaning, feeling and message. This does not mean, of course, that grammar or vocabulary will be better in the former. How could it be? Even if you are a native speaker, the richness of your language will depend on your level of education, your environment, the talents you possess and your willingness to read complex and varied texts. The difference lies in the nuances of the language and whether you need to think of the grammar and certain expressions or it comes to you naturally. Whether you need to think of the exemptions or they are part of you. Even if you do it fast, you still have to work hard in the background. In short, with a few exceptions, being bilingual and mastering a second language at a later age are not the same.
Pronunciation is the most obvious sign in most cases between learning a language as a child or as an adult. Our body and brain remain flexible, yet most people cannot change the physiology of the key organs and body parts participating in the process of speaking beyond a certain age. This is the case for many other skills like playing an instrument or ballet dancing. Certain movements and flexibility remain beyond reach. Claiming that some can develop native pronunciation, maybe 1% or 2% of the population, is not helpful. We have savants, linguistic savants too. They also forget to mention the role of hearing and absolute hearing (perfect pitch). People with such hearing have a significantly better chance of mastering any pronunciation, even as an adult. So unless you are in the 1-2% of the population, do not worry too much about pronunciation. They are the social skills that we focus in this collection of writings.
Another key difference between a bilingual and a second language is the process of learning itself. When you are very young, you do not have an already formed and established linguistic system with its grammar, tenses, metaphors, etc. You do not even have a learning style. By the time you start learning a second language as a young or older adult, you do have a very well-defined system. It is more and more difficult to 'switch off' and 'ignore' how your present system works. Being older also comes with its benefits when it comes to learning difficult concepts and complex expressions. An older person might master it quicker as they have already built quite an impressive vocabulary. But the difference remains. In the former, being bilingual and growing up with two languages, language becomes part of your everyday life. In the latter, learning a second language later in your life, you approach it like most other subjects, biology or history. It is something you need to learn and practise. It will never feel as natural as your first language. It will always remain work, something you need to learn and improve.
Neuroimaging and other methods have pointed in the direction that people use a different part of their brain for native languages (bilingual from birth/young age) and for a second language (learnt as an adult). This should not come as a surprise. Just because the brain remains incredibly flexible throughout life, it does not mean that development does not go through certain stages. At a young age, language probably develops with a developing brain. In older age, the already developed yet plastic brain will process it. One paper tried to refute this claim by comparing people who learnt a second language at the age of 4 and 10, and they found no difference. This article possibly showed that there was no difference between very young and young children. For us, it is not very helpful. A nice reminder of the importance of assumptions. This collection aims to help adults primarily, approximately from the age of 25  onwards, where a clear difference between the learning process probably exists.
What I could not establish is any convincing proof that the ability to become bilingual has some inherited prerequisites meaning that even if the child did not learn a second language from birth, they still could master it quickly as an adult because he/she came from a bilingual and multilingual family and some factors were planted in her body for future success. Again, for us, it does not make a huge difference. Some learn easier than others. Stop comparing and do it for your own growth. 
It is unnecessary and misleading to put too much emphasis on any of these linguistic and learning issues. Whilst science will never stop fine-tuning our knowledge on critical windows, pronunciation, grammar, and learning processes, for us, such questions are irrelevant. Learning a second language has tremendous benefits for autistic and neurodivergent people at any age. The relationship between such elements is far more complex than we give credit for, so it is not very useful to connect them or establish causation between them. Thinking about how critical window affects academic writing or how much easier it seems to get a gift (bilingual) rather than working hard for it (second language) will not make your life better. Both have many advantages and probably disadvantages. Comparison is a funny thing. If you compare a highly gifted and educated person who learnt a second language as an adult with someone who is native but with a significantly lower educational level and giftedness, you find what you were looking for.

Learning languages develop social skills

Learning a second language as an adult with autism has many therapeutic benefits. The following excerpts explore 6 potential benefits for autistic and neurodiverse people.

After discussing a few differences between bilingualism and a second language, I want to address the advantages of learning a language as an adult, mature person and or the benefit of living in a different culture for autistic people. When we learn our native language as a child, we learn how to say words, put together sentences, and the various ways of expressing ourselves. Most importantly, we learn the rules of social life and our relationship with others. We learn about the culture and the environment we live in. The family, the friends, the school, the shop, the public transport, the birthday card, and what to say and do when the dog dies. All of these social actions and interactions will be learnt through and by the language. Language is central to the development of our identity. Our self-confidence and self-worth are closely related to our ability to express ourselves through language. Language, culture and ethnicity are interrelated and form a much more complex network than talking about language in a vacuum.
What does all this mean for someone with autism? Autism belongs to the group of developmental conditions. Many skills, including language acquisition, thinking processes, verbal and non-verbal communication skills, attention, mind flexibility, emotions, etc., tend to develop slower and differently, often reaching the milestones at a much older age and many times in a different way. In terms of learning the rules of the social arena, this delayed development has a significant effect on autistic people's social functioning. By the time autistic people are ready to learn certain social skills, they are already behind and thus neglected. By the age of 10, 15, or 20, they should have already learnt skills like how to salute, what to say when someone asks you, “How are you?”, what to write on a birthday card and why, and how to behave in all sorts of social situations. However, many autistic people do not learn the trick at the age required by society. They are not ready. They are too self-absorbed, they lack introspection of their differences, they are in a constant struggle with more important things, they can’t pay attention, they can’t process events and so on and so forth. We all have our individual differences when it comes to skill development. But by the time we become adults, at least in the legal sense, we are already behind in most of the skills needed to survive in social and adult life in their broadest sense of the words. Simultaneously, by this time, many of us have managed to develop good coping mechanisms, a newly formed self-awareness and the ability to analyse and think critically. In other words, our bodies and mind are now ready to learn the things we could not do earlier as a result of our differences.
Here comes the indispensable benefit of moving to a different culture. It does not have to be a different country, albeit that would bring the most benefit. Entering a bicultural/bilingual relationship, building multi-cultural and multi-lingual friendships and starting to learn a second language as an adult are all excellent ways to learn those tricky social rules. Learning a second language will have at least two main effects: 1) the language itself and communication and 2) the mysteries of social life. Such a situation gives adults – especially the ones who missed out previously – the opportunity to learn and improve their social and interpersonal skills. Someone with autism will not simply learn foreign words, how to say apple or happy birthday in English, for example. They will learn why people say these things, how and when. Autistic people get a second chance in life. However, there are more things attached to this process that support the success and the therapeutic value of such experiences. When using a second language, you have to think of your words. Most of the time, the things you say will not come in the same 'automatic' mode. You have to divert your attention and cognition to the process of speaking and acting. Of course, sometimes you just say things the way they come, but most of the time, you will exercise a form of scrutiny. This has a significant advantage for autistic people who precisely, for this reason, prefer to write. Writing buys a bit more time to think through our thoughts. Moreover, autistic people enter a space that most of the time is hidden from them: the experience of tolerance and encouragement. As a foreigner or a person speaking a second language, you become a well-respected learner whose mistakes are tolerated and usually forgiven. An autistic person who used to be rude and troubled disappears in this learning space. This feeling of being tolerated and even supported, in its own right, gives invaluable confidence and inspiration for autistic people to improve. For many of us, this is possibly the first time when our mistakes were not reacted upon by but gently nudged.
Another benefit of learning a second language shows itself in the form of self-awareness. Autistic people who tend to be self-reflective yet lack insight into their difficulties soon will start realising that their approach to language and, indeed, to communication is different. This could be particularly useful for people who either do not have a diagnosis yet and do not know what causes their differences or individuals who are newly diagnosed and would like to use their newly gained framework as a support tool. Autistic people, when they start learning a second language, will notice that the process is much more than language itself. We can exploit this process and turn it into a therapeutic tool. We can experiment more bravely with self-expression, acting, gestures and the whole range of social skills as, more often than not, autistic people will receive more understanding and tolerance for their mistakes.  Native speakers often laugh when foreigners confuse words or say something with a funny accent. They often joke and laugh. Autistic people learn a second magic remedy: the skill of laughing at themselves. “I was there, it was beautiful to see my children burn”. What he meant was, “I was there, it was beautiful to see my children born”. One letter difference. Laughing is a skill and antidote that most people with autism find hard to learn. Perfectionism does not go well with social skills. But learning a foreign language does. And then, slowly, we learn to employ this skill in other areas of our life, reducing the side effects of perfectionism by letting those barriers down inch by inch and taking small steps and risks.
The benefits do not end here. Do not stop at learning a second language, but expand it to thinking and talking to yourself in a foreign language. If the claim holds that as an adult, you mostly use a different part of the brain and new pathways when using a second language (learnt as an adult), then the hypothesis is even more probable. The hypothesis is that when you start thinking and talking to yourselves in a second language, you enter a new space. In other words, you do not have the same automatic access to your earlier, usually adverse events as far as your social skills are concerned: memories, negative self-talk, involuntary copying mechanism to set events in motion and the unhealthy thinking patterns developed as a result of bullying, abuse, misunderstandings etc. Thinking in a foreign language not only gives you space to distance yourself from unhelpful thoughts but, to an extent, can help separate the inherent features of autism from the acquired traits of adverse life events, including the ones that are rooted in people's negative responses to your autism. Needless to say, this separation is not fully possible, as many things that have been interacting from an early age become your core characteristics. Or put it differently, there is a limit to how long and how well the yolk can be separated from the white once put together in a bowl. But many of your self-activating responses will fade away and even disappear. The benefit comes not only from moving away from automatic responses but from the newly gained opportunity to build novel, more positive and productive coping mechanisms. If a reaction under certain circumstances hardly changes, then there is a good chance that this is rooted in your autism and or other rather genetic processes. You will learn very quickly that in most situations, many of your previous, well-practised automatic responses will not come up or not with the same speed, giving you space to re-create those answers by re-learning the social. And then you can really work with what you should have been working with: your autism. What to keep and what to improve.

Stepping out from our cultural, ethnic and linguistic comfort zone has a high therapeutic potential that we hardly know, research and apply. We can only suggest to anyone with autism and their parents to start experimenting with such approaches creating opportunities to befriend people from different cultures, learn a second language and be involved in situations when you do have to use a language other than your native one (one that you acquire as an adult). If you are about to become an adult, start learning a second language. Learning a second language at any age will have many positive effects on a person with autism. More research hopefully will be done in exploring the therapeutic implications of a second language for individuals with autism. Most people cannot change their country and start living somewhere else. There are many other options, so be creative. Go for a holiday, find a language course and get a summer job. Find a digital friend, online community and start a blog, in a second language.

The autistic employee: the best

Autistic people are amongst the best employees. It is a shame that most of the time, they cannot go through the recruitment process. See why and how you can change this.

The National Autistic Society has a petition to call on the government to support people with autism in the workplace. “More needs to be done to support autistic adults into and at work. Some workplaces are full of too much information; too many sounds, lights, stares, glares – and too little understanding. The Government has committed to halving the disability employment gap. But without more understanding from both employers and the Government, autistic adults will continue to be left behind, their abilities overlooked. We’ve waited too long for change.”

This is certainly an important thing to do. Open plan offices, phone calls all the time, colleagues who sneeze louder than the fireworks (incredibly annoying), fire alarm testing without any notice, etc. But employment starts with recruitment. I have completed many job application forms. And I am always surprised when it comes to the question about disability.

“As part of our organisation’s commitment to equal opportunities, we will seek to invite candidates with a disability to a selection process should they meet the minimum essential criteria for the role. Please confirm if you have a disability and wish your application to be considered on this basis. “

If you say yes, it means that you want to be considered on the basis of your disability. Then, you can disclose whether you need any help at the interview. Many forms will not even allow you to disclose a disability unless you want to be considered that way. 

That is just wrong. What if you want to be considered because you are good just like anybody else, yet you have a disability and you need reasonable adjustment at the interview?

This option is simply not offered. You are either considered on the basis of your disability or you can’t ask for support. This is a great example of discrimination. 

“If invited for an interview, do you have any particular needs i.e BSL signer, audio requirements that need to be taken into account?”

You can see where I am going here. Questions around reasonable adjustment always have something to do with the physical. I am surprised they missed large print and wheelchair access.

Then comes the question about our relationship with our disability, usually along the lines of "do you consider yourself disabled?" Guess what, for most of us, the answer is not. I am not disabled you areas you are unable to understand my highly developed world. But. And it is a BUT with capital letters. You are the majority, so you tend to set the rules. I am disabled based on your criteria and definition. And the question should be: "are you considered disabled under the Equality Act 2010? Yes, that's simple.

If we can't even get the basics right what do we expect at an interview and the workplace?
Q: Interviewer     S: self-talk (oops) or thinking
A: answer       C: comment

Q: “Tell me a bit about yourself”
S: What!? What do you want? Do you want to know my qualifications? It is on my CV. My hobbies, marital status? This is not your business. A bit? How much exactly do you want to know, and about what? A bit of what?
A: well…
C: Either no answer, or listing the facts from your CV, or some sort of nonsense. Yes, your hobbies and what the dog did this morning. And the bit part, well, this is another question.

Solution: Prepare with a script and memorise a good sentence or two. Practice so it will look as if you are a natural.

Q: “Why do you want to become a manager?”
S: Who the hell wants to become a manager? I applied for this job because I want to work for the Company, make a difference and improve practice. If I wanted to become a manager, I would have applied for a business role with Audi or something. 
S: I have to say something so let’s talk about Company X then.
C: If you are lucky this is what they meant. Usually, you are not that lucky.

Solution: No matter what is the question, being well prepared about the company and the job helps. Try not to cite all the statistics and cold facts but rather your motive.

Q: "Give me an example of when you worked as part of a team.”
S: I do not work in teams. How do they define a team? Team? I don’t play sport. Team of what?
C: I gave an example when I failed to work as part of a team.
A: “It was an inter-professional session, and we were given a task to solve it together. But I quickly realised that it was a mathematical anomaly. So, there was no point in discussing the options because you could not solve the problem. I tried to explain it to the other team members, but they became very cross with me. They did not understand how I managed to make those calculations.  Except for one guy, the rest of the group have never talked to me again. But I reflected, and next time, I let them do the work, and I only stepped in when they were about to fail the exercise.
C: At this point, you are sweating, and your world is slowly falling apart. Something is not quite right here, your body is in fight-or-fly mode.

Solution: Team working usually comes up, as they are obsessed with it, so memorise a script or two about how brilliant you are in teams. Try also to write down at least a dozen versions of how one might ask about teamwork. 

Q: “Give me an example of when you managed a project”
S: A project? I am not a project manager. I organised events, conferences, restructured services, designed webistes, managed a small team, but projects? I don’t know.  Maya, think.  Search the database. What type of project?  Project, project, project. Maya needs a project … what type of project?
C: Very long silence and signs of exhaustion by this point. You are staring at the floor or looking out of the window, waiting for some sort of miracle. Then out of the blue, you finally manage to say something very (in)appropriate.
A: “I love puzzles.”
C: At this point, the interviewers, who were clearly in a high managerial position and mastered their poker faces, could not hold it together any longer and burst down into laughter. You cease to exist at this point. You have no idea any longer what is going on.
You prepared. You have years of experience. But these vague questions, words like projects, simply do not click with your world. You work in teams every day, yet you cannot make the link. You run dozens of projects successfully, yet in this situation, the project has a literal meaning. You can’t handle expressions like a bit.

Solution: Practice makes it perfect. Try to look up questions and their variations, work out possible answers, and learn them. Build up a database and also learn how to mix and match your scripts.

Q: "So tell me a bit about work and life balance, how do you maintain it?"
A: I do not have work and life balance. I love working and studying. I do not like going out much. I have a few friends, but I prefer working and doing my own things.”
C: You found out later, wrong answer. Managers who want to go home early on a Friday afternoon do not like employees who are better trained and definitely do not want to worry about their people's mental health. They cannot imagine that working actually can be good for you. May I add, mostly in the public sector. Hence, gifted people, funnily enough, are much better positioned in the private and business sectors and capitalism, where output and quality matter, but this is for another blog. 

Solution: script, script and script. There are approximately 50 questions and their variations you need a script. Memorising for most of us is not an issue, so stick to it. And if you have issues with pretending, well, do not. Only autistic people seem to care about such things.

C: You walk out from the interview and the only thing you can think of is that you have just had a TIA (mini-stroke). So you do not talk to anyone, just find a quiet place to examine yourself. You can write, you can read your writing, you can talk.  You give a quick call to a friend. He can understand you and you can understand him. No facial droops. You did not have a stroke. So what the fuck was that?

Feedback:  “For our company, a healthy work-life balance is very important. You admitted that you do not have much social life. You are a maverick, not a team player. You can’t work in a team, in this place, teamwork is very important.”
Q: Interviewer     S: self-talk (oops) or thinking
A: answer       C: comment


Disclosing disability before an interview – Let us know if you have any disability and need reasonable adjustment. Maya did.

C: You get an email that states who will be the two people on the panel. You prepare. Two people are not too bad. You arrive. They let you wait for 20 minutes because they are behind and they need to have lunch. You are sitting outside and someone comes out.

Q: “Complete this form.”

C: You spend ten minutes with the form, but it does not make any sense. It was designed for people who are already in the industry. You are not. But you try to do your best. You always do. You hear voices. Laughter. There are many voices. And very loud laughter. You slowly become anxious. That sounds like more than two people. Someone is coming out again.

A: “I am sorry I tried to do the form, but I could not get this number.”

Q: “Oh, don’t worry, this form is not for you, you just should have signed it and said it is not applicable.”

C: You walk in. Four people are sitting behind a table. You are now very anxious. You do your powerpoint presentation. One of the interviewers literally goes mental and shouts at you.

Q: “How do you dare to say that…”

C: You have no idea what was wrong with your presentation and why she became cross with you. You find it out later. Anyway, the others calmed her down, and they moved to the questions.

And those questions again, with or without disclosing your autism.

Q: “How would you manage a project, and how would you engage others?”
S: How would I do a research project? So, it is about research.

C: You give a good description of the steps, some of the obstacles and how you would deal with them. What if you do not get the data or can’t recruit participants. You did well. Until the feedback session comes.

Q: ”What are your weaknesses?”

A: “I have many. Sometimes, I stress out when I have to multitask. I am not very good at meetings, and I can be quite anxious when I have to talk in front of others. I...”

C: A very dangerous question for an autistic person. They are honest and perfectionists. They tend to focus on their weaknesses to get better.

Solution: And again, a script can help. Otherwise, you will let you know your weaknesses. They are not interested. But then, why to ask questions like this? If it is nothing else but memorising a script, what is the point? Good question. The interview then turns into a performance, not to an opportunity to explore who is the best for the job.

Feedback:

Q: "The presentation was too academic"."Full of references and complex language."

S: But they said in the advert that they wanted the best people, with strong first-class degrees, people who would do research projects, innovate and change practice. How could it possibly be too academic?

Q: "You misunderstood many questions, we meant project within the company, not in research. Next time, write down the question, and ask if you are not sure".

S: Seriously? I was sure. Project means research project. You did not specify what kind of project, and in the job advert, you said we could be involved in research projects.  Ok, the project can mean many other things, but should you not stop me and let me know that this is not what you meant? You let me talk about a topic that you know was not about the question. Someone who disclosed that s/he was autistic. Not good.

The examples could go on and on. But it would just repeat the same pattern and shocking state of practice.

These interviews and the whole selection process do commit everything that autistic people do not handle very well. They do not tell you who will be present, or what the structure will be. They do not repeat a question or help you understand the question. If you do take it the wrong way around, they do not stop you. They assume you are stupid. People with autism are not stupid. Let’s just highlight this. Yes, they can appear to be weird in an interview situation. They have significant difficulties with vague and open questions. They take things literally. They are anxious. They are perfectionists. They might dress differently and forget to smile. 

But they are great at their job.  

We need to rethink the recruitment processes. Not just people with autism, but introverts and anyone who is not a great actor are in trouble in these situations.

Do you want someone who works instead of gossiping too much? Someone who has attention to detail? 
Who will deliver? 
Who can hyper-focus? 
Someone you can trust? 

Employ more people with autism. They actually think that a workplace is about work and not a place for social gatherings. 

They are efficient, enthusiastic and funny. 

Adjust your recruitment process so they will not be discriminated against. It is a win-win situation. They just come with a different manual. It's rocket science. Ask specific questions. Give them time. Let them know who will be there. Ask the question again if they took it the wrong way around. Ask it again. Make them comfortable, leave the outmoded one bad guy, one good guy thing. 

And even better. Arrange a practice day for them. Test their performance on the job. You will get a very different picture. An interview is one-sided and cannot objectively and reliably establish who is the best match.

Do you wonder why we are where we are? Why our beloved NHS or other public sector is struggling? Employ less normal people who can network, smile and call in sick and hire more autistic and gifted people who work, deliver and perform.

The autistic mind: it is special

Are autistic people gifted? How come sometimes they appear so ignorant? Are they brilliant or are they mad? They are both. They are special. The following articles explore such contradictions.

It is like a never-ending tightrope dance between madness and brilliance. And sometimes, when you stop and you look down, the height makes you dizzy and attracts you like a magnet. It feels like every moment of life is about making sure you do not lose your balance and do not fall into this mysterious space. And if you now see a line, with brilliance in one end and madness on the other, you do not quite understand it. It is not walking a straight line. It is constantly running in circles. The boundaries of madness and brilliance are blurred. You never really know where you are on that circle. You have no reference points. You see what others do not see and fail to grasp what others perceive. 

The circle is gently drifting in the universe, but the stars are somewhat the same. Apparently, they are different sizes, shapes, colours and brightness. They guide and show the way. Maybe. For me, it is a rather homogenous and uniform space. The stars are there. They shine. But the difference is meaningless as the difference between them is minuscule compared to the difference between all of them and me. I cannot make use of them most of the time. 

The universe still attracts you. It makes you believe you can fly and gives you great aspiration to keep on running. It is worthy, they say. But when you look inside the circle, there is a dense black void of space. So strong. So tempting. It whispers to you. It wants you to jump and swim weightlessly in the mysterious space. Where you can stop. Where you can finally end this constant dance between madness and brilliance and melt into integrity. 

The task is not smaller but finding a way to stay in that circle. Never staring at the Universe so long that the stars blind you, and never letting in the invitation of this mysterious space so deeply that you lose your balance. 
Our quest is to find a way to embrace both this madness and brilliance with grace. 

Or maybe all this is just an illusion. Neither madness nor brilliance exists. Just the myriad of different reflections of the stars confuses me. And the secret? The secret is probably courage and curiosity. Keep running in this infinite uncertainty.
It is tiring to try to find a way to connect with the world when Mother Nature and the G-d build amazing brains but forget to build a bridge between your brain and the world outside. A bridge where you can easily come and go. Or there might have been some miscommunication; they had started to build bridges simultaneously from the two ends, but they never happened to meet in the middle. Who knows? All you know is that you spend a considerable length of time figuring out how you can get from one point to the other. To the other side. You try everything: building bridges, digging channels, learning to jump big enough, flying with a balloon, anything that can take you to the other side and back with ease.
 
And you are certainly doing better and better. But it is tiring. It requires energy. Motivation. Will-power. It is not difficult to see then why you consider again and again the possibility of staying inside. Forever. And sometimes you are stuck. You get lost on your way, in the in-between. 

The bridge you started to walk on suddenly disappears in the mist. You lose connection, and for long moments, hours or days at times, you do not know where you are. These are very scary moments. You just hope that some form of road will re-appear again. It always happened so far, so you are optimistic. But the question is always there, at the back of your head, what if one day it will not be there? 

Being stuck on one side or the other does not make much difference. One is a kind of reference point to the other. One does not make much sense without the other. One gives meaning to the other, one outside “reality” and one inside “imaginary”. Maybe. Maybe not. You have a feeling that it is just the other way round, actually, but let’s discuss this later.

But when the connection is not clear and stable, the reflection becomes distorted. It is easy to get lost and make mistakes. You try to fill the gaps, the missing pieces of the picture. But if you think the wrong piece into the picture and act on it, you can end up in real trouble. Why risk to get out, then? What is the point? Especially when you can get so much fun inside. Why the effort to walk through the bridge to watch a movie shot by others when you can just stay inside and watch yours in your own comfort, enjoying it just as much, if not even more? Well, certainly a bit more. Why the effort to walk through the bridge to have a laugh when you can just stay inside, tell a joke and have a (much better) laugh? Is it worth it? Working so hard just to get lost. Just to be hurt, lied and disillusioned. If you analyse, of course. 

And when you do go out, and you do eventually arrive, you end up watching a horror movie even if it has started as an exciting thriller; you end up in tears even if it has started as a promising comedy. Why would you do this? Again and again? That makes no sense. They say certain methods help and can help you get out. They appear to be working. They can take the sharp edge of your rationale and blur your vision. Yet, everything will still happen exactly the same way, they just detach you from your story. Depersonalise you. You become the second or third-line actor of the movie instead of being the main character. Walking through the bridge becomes easier, the movies are less frightening, and although you still do not laugh, you stop crying at last. You are hypnotised.

But is it good enough? Does it really make a difference? Space might have been created, a vast and fluid space. Now, you have to figure out what to do in this new space. Getting a space will not help in its own right. You need tools for what to do in this space, with this space, being the space.

I do not take on their offer to get me out. I want to be the main character. I want to stay with my story. I continue to get out, get lost and find my way back again until one day I will get llost forever.
It is well-known that many people with autism love, and it is possibly fair to say that they are slightly obsessed with all sorts of brain games and puzzles, and they are quite good at them. Not necessarily savants, but still, many will score high. Yes, we can mention Lumosity or BrainHQ or else. In a previous article, I have already addressed the arguments about whether these so-called brain games were beneficial or not and whether the skills were transferable or not. I say yes, for both, but I admit, it is a bit more complicated than this. Let’s illustrate this question with a short story.

Maya bought a new shoe insole just to make walking a bit more cushioned and comfortable. The first hurdle was faced and solved well. Measure it to your sole, identify the right dotted line on the insole and cut it to your size. A kind of puzzle, right? No problem. The second hurdle, put it in your shoes. And Maya did it. Let’s see what a gifted brain looks like when it is not so gifted.

“Something is not right here. It does not stick.”
“Let’s put on the shoes and try them.”
“It is moving, it does not stay in place. These stick to my sole.”

A careful inspection followed.

“Who designed this insole? The sticky bit is on the wrong side!”

Friends are watching, which made Maya even more excited.

“Maya…”
“I am busy. I do not get it. This is stupid.”

“Maya…”
“Who was this idiot who put the sticky bit on the top?”

“Maya, listen..”
“Maya is busy. Can’t you see? This sticks to my sole. This is not right.”

People are collapsing with laughter in all directions.

“Maya”
"Maya"
.
.

“Maya”
“This should be the other way round, it is on the wrong side.”

“Maya, .. Maya, please…”
“I told you. Leave me alone. I need to sort this. This insole is wrong.”

“Maya”
“WHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAT?!”

“Turn it upside down!”

Beautiful moments, life stops completely for seconds, and you just hope death will be something similar journey.

“Ah!”
“It works.”

Laughter has not stopped all day long and after.

“All right, guys, there is no such game in Lumosity as how to put an insole into the shoes, okay? So what?!”

Well, there are certainly no such games on how to brush your teeth, do your shoelaces, choose your attire, and all sorts of exercises are certainly missing. But of course, they are missing, these are unnecessary and illogical things to do. For an autistic mind, at least. So maybe quick mental arithmetic is transferable to calculating medicine, but possibly not much help with every day (i.e. boring) self-skills. We need more research on the link between memory and hair brushing, speed of processing and making a pizza (as we often manage to put the pizza in the oven with the packaging under it, not mentioning the burn scars) and between reasoning ability and getting on the bus.

Maybe. Maybe not.

Maybe we should just learn to laugh together more.
I have just had an amazing weekend. Great fun, really. Thanks to good friends, their washing machine, a broken handle, and the screws. In other words, why do we have so many different screw heads, and above all, in one washing machine?

It is possibly not a surprise that the history of screws can be traced back to Ancient times. Of course, the first screws were made of wood; the metal ones started to become widespread in the 15th century, and it was not until the 19th century that screws could be mass-produced. And this very soon turned into a competition: who can produce the strongest, fittest and most creative screw head. And open a new market each time: every new screw head comes with a new screwdriver. 

We have the flat head, the round head, raised, mushroom, button and pan head. This is just the shape of the head. We have the slot (line) with an open or closed-end, Philips (cross), hexagon, not the Allen one, it is a hexagon socket whatever the difference is, Frearson (little cross), Robertson (square), Torx (star), double square, double hex and a few more. Here we find modernity's unique characteristics again; the suffocating alternatives and excess of screw heads.

But why in one washing machine? After checking a few instruction manuals and some youtube videos about how to open a washing machine with a broken handle, I passionately jumped on the first screws. Job done well, it was a traditional line or slot one; we all have this type of screwdriver. Then, two more came, resembling a hexagon. If you have ever bought furniture that you had to assemble (the one where the manual says it only takes two hours, but for you 8 and 8 only, not 10 because you only had to dismantle it twice. Once, when you realise, obviously towards the end, that you mixed the left side with the right and when you are nearly there just to learn that you forgot to slide down the back panel), then you should have a nice collection of Allen keys. If you are a more experienced player, you keep a second set of screwdrivers in your toolbox: Allen keys of different sizes. This type of heads are all sorted. 

Then you just slide down the panel, and here we go. It did not slide down. At this point, we (Maya and Maya) were just about to give up. But here comes the Internet again. A fascinating video about how to place a fishing line around the door, pull it gently and hurrah, the door opens wide. Not for you. I tried for fifteen minutes and gave up. Back to the screws.

Perseverance paid off, we found out why we could not just slide down the panel. Two more hidden screws. Just for a change, we encountered a couple of Phillips ones, but after many years of practice, you prepared. You have a third set of screwdrivers for cross heads, so no problem, we could open these ones too. In the meantime, you more and more often talk to G-d. But why? Please, tell me why? And you move on. 

Then, something else is there. Nothing works. It is not a line, not a cross, not a hexagon. What is it? The mobile phone comes in handy. You took a couple of pictures to analyse the shape. Please, tell me it is not another one! It is. A star. Bad luck, no suitable screwdriver. You try scissors, tweezers, the end of the spoon and whatever you can find in your household. Then, you have no choice but to rush to the nearby shop to acquire a fourth set of screwdrivers. Obviously, at least in 8 different sizes. You cannot risk it, can you? Such a great decision, because later on, we found stars again, and in a bigger size. Eventually, we found the hidden door opening inside the machine, and this time, the door indeed opened.

And you just hope that you do not have to repair the fridge or something else soon just to discover that you are still missing at least another five types of screwdriver sets. My hands right now look like I was self-harming all weekend. Lucky that I do not have a shrink. Who knows, would he believe me? Just in case, I think I will be hiding my hands for a few days.

A few lessons learnt: 

First, not everything works that you see online. The trick in the video was with the fishing line; the door popped open because the pin system was made of plastic. Not ours. It was metal. So tight, that I could hardly move it with my hand. Not the type you would just open with a fishing line naturally. 

And it is also useful if you find a video of exactly the same kind of washing machine, so less hidden screws. 

And finally, don’t celebrate with Tequila. The salt and the fresh lemon are not compatible with cuts and wounds on the hand. 

Having said this, I carried out a quick research. Apparently, traditional medicine suggests that salt water (or the more concentrated form, the licking of salt from your hand) promotes wound healing as it helps kill certain types of bacteria, whilst lemon is a mild antiseptic and astringent.

And as always internet did not disappoint me. There are fascinating articles about the history of screws as well as short courses on the various types. I still have no idea why we have four different screw heads in one washing machine, though. But I learnt that this story probably does not end here, and I need to be prepared to buy the next set of screwdrivers. Sooner or later.
They say autistic people’s brain is different. It is wired differently. So it should not come as a surprise that they find it difficult to live with this brain. We can’t share it with you. Hence, you might see autistic people as weirdos, freaks, and nutters, which makes sense, and it is ok. You do not think about the things we do. You do not see what we see. You do not sense the world the same way we do. It makes perfect sense. But it does not make it right. Assuming we are the problem, and not you, or us.

Of course, we feel alone. In the end, we can’t share ourselves. Hence, it is so painful being with others. It feels even more lonely. When we are on our own, it feels just right. But when we are out there, and we cannot really connect, it feels lonely. Sometimes, we just watch you. You seem so happy. You enjoy each other, you share feelings, you are like a family. We just stand there, and we want to be with you, but you know it will not be the same. We can join your dance, but it is not our dance. We can sense your joy, but we cannot immerse in it. We can absorb a different world, but we cannot show it to you. Even if you invite us, we will not be able to swim with you just alongside you.

So we either give up and let our inner world absorb us; or we desperately try to figure out how to fit in. How to be good. How to be liked and accepted. But then, we might end up being more disconnected than ever before. We cannot read the signs or understand the language any longer. We become a mimicry. Only an impression of the moment. To please you. 

We need to compromise. We need to negotiate. The world was built by others, and we have to live in it. Fit in it. Learn to go along.

We need to learn about each other. You do not have imaginary friends. You have more than 100 facial expressions. You inherently know what we cannot even grasp. You do not record and watch back the movies of every moment. You do not spend hours making sense of what has just happened to you when people are involved. Fascinating. Depressing. Puzzling.

You do not take things literally. The letter said “you have to leave your bag and phone in a cloakroom. You cannot take anything with you to the tests. You can only take a bottle of water”.  It does not say drink, it says water. Why we can’t take a bottle of juice? Or tea?  Words are important. Words try to express what you try to say and mean. So we need help: “The letter says water but I drink tea. Is it alright to take it with me? It is made of water.” 
Then you are surprised. You do not know whether we are joking or teasing you. 

“Of course you can.” – she laughed. I laughed too. But I did not feel it was funny. It was painful. It was just what always happens. You laugh with them. 

Smile and laugh become your best friends. It is better to allow others to laugh at you than be confused or, even worse, make a mistake. We are tired of being shouted at.

Smile works. Smile hides. Smile connects.

Your pain, your confusion, your anger. Smile lets you in without joining. We like to connect through disconnections. Smile protects us without being defensive. 

So, never believe in a smile. Most of the time, it is not what you think. But that is the point. Because you do not want to know what lies behind the smile anyway.

It is the deal. So smile. The black box of autism. The perfect simulation of me, of you, and of our relationship.
Trust. Trust is a complicated concept. Often, people with autism and other hidden disabilities cannot process other people and their intentions. The messages are confusing, or they just zone out because the situation becomes overwhelming. Often, they completely misunderstand what is happening. And you guessed they pay a high price to learn this. Bullying, abuse, or humiliation are well-known companions to an autistic life. They lose trust early on because the picture is not clear. And because they have been hurt for who they are. Most of them always analyse everything (obsessively, perhaps). But it is a necessary self-defence mechanism and survival skill. 

If you do not trust someone when you should, you might miss an opportunity, good fun, love or a potential friendship, but you will survive and be just fine. 

Alone but alive. 

If this happens the other way around, it can be potentially fatal. When you have no clue what signals the other person is sending to you, things become complicated. And not all people are good. And most of them have learnt this. They have been hurt more than enough times. Predators always find vulnerable people quicker than people who want to help, who want to be your friend, who could love you. 

It is not only an issue with predators in the literal sense. Your boss, work colleagues, so-called friends and professionals are all predators to an autistic mind more or less regularly. They do not necessarily want the best for you. 

With age and experience, things get better as you build your database, but you might still decide to miss something good rather than being misused and hurt. 

When you can’t see the difference between a cat and a tiger, approaching everything as a potential tiger is less dangerous than the other way around. And it is ok, too.

The autistic and the world

There is the autistic world, and then there is the world. And the two have a strange relationship. There are connectors, the main one is our shrink. You cannot be autistic without a shrink. And without research and experts.

A few months ago, I was researching suicide in my work, and I came across a blog. It listed 28 suicide methods, including the following descriptors that were based on a published study:

Lethality: How likely is the method to cause death (where 0% is no chance, and   100% is absolute certainty)

Time: An opinion on the length of time the method will require to produce death

Agony: The amount of pain and discomfort you would expect from the use of the particular method (ranked on a scale of 0 to 100 where 0 is no pain/discomfort, and 100 is the most pain/discomfort possible)

My immediate reaction was that none of them were as painless and instant as one might think. Then, moving on, I was contemplating that there are not many facts out there. One thing, however, seems to be quite certain. We will leave the material world sooner or later, the way our mind knows it, so we will find out one day, whether we like it or not, what happens when we die. Or not. 

So let’s find out what life has to offer regardless of whether it appears to be painful or not, whether we enjoy it or not, because you can’t turn certain decisions back. It is, of course, a very different matter when a 'rational' decision is made because someone is terminally ill or just wants to die peacefully. Otherwise, suicide decisions are not necessarily made in the 'rational' sphere. And that is one of the problems with statistics and the various theories in mental health. It tries to rationalise, simplify and numericise the mysterious, the unspoken and the entangled.

One issue with statistics is that when the effect of the variables is considered, a seemingly trivial factor can become significant in the presence of another element. We have methods to look at this, but the number of variables and combinations is simply too huge to examine. We also have to remember that while statistics work well with significant events that indeed create vulnerabilities, it is almost always the insignificant that pushes people over the edge. We lack methods that can model the effect and likelihood of insignificant events' significance in the chemistry of the moment.

The other problem is us humans. When it comes to understanding the origin of mental disorders, we have a possible number of genetic combinations close to the infinite that makes us 8,388,608 possible combinations of the 23 chromosome pairs per person, 70,368,744,177,664 variations per couple; plus, we have about 25 000 genes, some of them with more than one alleles, and the SNPs (a few millions of single nucleotide polymorphisms); we need to consider the random crossovers and the random mutations… not mentioning further epigenetic modifications and the interactions with the environment. It is in this water where we are fishing for one truth: a single biological or environmental origin or a particular combination of a (limited) number of factors for certain behaviours and special needs to control and make predictions. Like. oh, your parents are divorced...let's apply attachment theory said the social worker. He is shouting, abusing me, let's give him a jab to calm him down said the nurse. 

Have you ever stopped smoking? Drinking? To try to lose weight? Do you remember the carving attacks? Can you recall any moment when you ceased to exist and could only follow your urge? Hunger, sex, addiction, crying, laughing, anything? This is how one can best imagine how 'mental health' or rather a different state of mind works, but for a prolonged period. At those moments, you have no access to your 'rationale'. You lose touch with existence. The way we prefer to define existence. You stop celebrating the moment. Whether it is physical pain or psychological, it overtakes you. You and your pain become one. Just the opposite that happens in hypnosis or meditation. In those states, you realise that you are not your pain. You are not your body. You are not your thoughts.

In many professions, we are getting better at talking about and managing self-harm. We now accept that some people need an extra layer of stimuli for various reasons. But suicide, it remains a controversial act.

Many methods came up with different graphs of how an urge, anger or depression develops and overtakes. You only have to learn how the sensation grows and intervene in time before the peak. Right? No, not really. It does not work like this.

Let’s have an illustration with the model of stages of escalation:



The first thing you notice is that it resembles the Gaussian curve. We really like describing events with this ingenious bell-shaped curve, yet there is no indication at all that the length of the stages works like this. In fact, this graph assumes that the peak is a relatively short period. It is not. Not in 'mental health' and most 'problem behaviour'. This model and most theories assume and state that we can learn to feel the curve, in other words, the increasing tension or sensation (anger, depressed mood, high spirit, etc.), so we only need to learn techniques about how to de-escalate before it reaches its peak. Start a breathing exercise, count to 10, and go for a walk.

One little problem with this approach is that it assumes that we feel the growing urge. It does not consider the fact that many people with autism and other cognitive and developmental conditions and certain mental health problems do not have this connection with their body and inner world. They have sensory processing disorders, as they call it. Some of them are more relevant to this issue:

Sensory craving – an urge to receive additional sensory stimulation, but when they have the stimulation, they do not feel satisfied. This can result in disorganisation and the need for even more stimulation

Proprioceptive – they have difficulties interpreting the sensory stimuli that are received through the muscles and joints.

Interoception – they have difficulties interpreting the sensory stimuli received from internal organs (toilet use, hunger, thirst, cold, hot, somatic complaints).

In other words, you do not have a growing sensation in you that you need to go to the toilet. You have 'toilet attacks'. The moment you feel you need to go, it is already almost too late. You are already sweating, you are in pain, and you have literally 30 seconds to reach the toilet. You sit, you read, but you are not getting cold. Then you have a 'cold attack'. You start shaking; you suddenly can’t move your finger any longer because you are freezing cold. You get up from the chair, and you nearly fall. You have not noticed that your legs started becoming numb. You did not change your position. You have no connection with your body.

Let’s use a bold modification of the previous chart:



This begs many questions. How can we teach to intervene before the peak? How can we notice it? How long do the stages last? For many people, sensory processing disorders are real. We know that it is quite frequent for people with autism and ADHD, but we lack research on how frequent it is in other mental health problems. What is the space that has been created between the trigger and the peak that swallows the individual and gets lost in it?  Yet, it can play a key role in various behaviour issues and also in self-harm. Treatments are literally non-existent, except the golden ones that work for everything: diet, exercise, balanced life, brain games, etc.  Our understanding of self-harm and the many forms of mental health problems remain inadequate, and the models are simplistic and as such, not helpful or even dangerous.
When you feel depressed, and the world becomes a dark and cold place, people keep on saying that you should not feel this way, that there is a lot of good thing in your life; it is your fault; you cannot afford it; we all have problems; stop feeling self-pity. Let’s move on. Let’s go out.  And so on…

You know they probably want to help, but it does not work like this. Once, my dog was injured. There was a fresh wound that was bleeding. And the first thing she did was to retreat into her world. Go to a quiet place. She did not eat, she did not listen to her name, she did not want you to touch her. She went into solitude and started licking her wound. The wound was bleeding, and it was painful. She had to concentrate on the injury. It was there. It was real. It hurts. 

For hours or even days, she was just licking the wound. Then, the wound slowly reacts. The bleeding stops, the first signs of healing appear, and the pain starts to ease. Then, she was ready to come out of her solitude for a short time, eat and interact. But she still spent plenty of time on her own with her wound. Once the wound started to heal and the new tissue began to develop, she was getting better and gradually became herself. Has she ever been the same? No, she hasn’t. She changed. And this is how it should be.

Why would be the mind and the heart so different? When something happens to you, when you lose something, whether it is your past or future, you are injured. You do not have a visible wound, but your heart is bleeding, your mind is sinking, and everything inside and outside is shaking. Your identity, your objectives, your relationships, everything. And the last thing you want to hear is “do not think of the past”, “do not think of your wounds”, “you cannot change it anyway”. “See the future”. This is great advice. I use it all the time. But not when I am already disappearing.

Because now you are not only in pain, but you got the message as well. You are incompetent. You are lazy. You are selfish. You are, you are...

You do need positive support, you do have to hear that it is not the end of the world, but, when you are not well, or you have just lost something, whether it is something within or outside, you do need to travel inside. And you need the support from people around you to let you take this journey. Sometimes for days, weeks but sometimes for long months or even years. The experience is real, and it is painful. The mental pain is real. And you can only build a new future if you get the foundation right. And the foundation is accepting and acknowledging that things have changed permanently, and it never will be the same. 

It does not help when friends and professionals start telling you to pull yourself together. You will. One day. Or another. You know you should. You are not stupid. But you are in pain. Real pain. Once you stopped the bleeding. Once you took care of that wound. Once you made sure it would not be infected. Once you did everything you could to support the development of new tissue. Once you...

When it all starts – not as if we could give the date and time –  during the darkest and most frightening days if the family, friends and professionals really want to help, do not make people feel even more miserable by sending out messages that they are incompetent. Gently support them, make sure they do not lose complete touch with the world, but allow them to feel the pain and the loss. Because it is real for them. They need to cry. They need to be angry. They have the right to be disappointed. It takes time to process what happened. If happened at all. It is irrelevant. It is real for them.

Sometimes, it just comes. Why now and not before, why you and not somebody else, why nobody noticed it, why could you not figure it out? Why they cannot help? Why…

The amount of unanswered questions that suddenly arise is overwhelming. And you need support and permission to do this. And these are the most vulnerable days. You cannot talk about it yet because you do not even know what you feel and what is happening. You cannot share because you are so confused. Don’t push them away because of your inner frustration. If you want to help, but you cannot do much at this stage, and you feel frustrated, then just be with them, hold their hands, gently stroke their head, cover them up and make them a nice cup of tea. Ask. What can I do?

That would be better than telling them to get up and move on when they are not quite ready yet, when their body feels so heavy that they physically can’t move their legs and arms. When you get sick, suffer from a cold or any other physical disease, you are allowed to stay in bed for a couple of days, not eat or just specific food, sleep a lot and just feel miserable. Why is it different when you have a mental disease? When you catch a cold, your immune system starts fighting it off and most of the time, it will succeed. When something happens, and you face mental ill-health, your mental immune system and your mind need the same recovery. It has to fight off the invader. For your cold you take medicine. For your loss, you take time. For your cold, your body answers with the immune response. And for your loss? It takes time to go through the cold, it takes time to go through mental difficulties. And sometimes it will stay with you. Stop fighting. Love it. Embrace it. Learn to live with it.

When someone has a physical disability, has a car accident and loses his leg, it does not help if we keep on saying, you can do it, get up and run, you just have to stay positive and believe in it. Mindfulness. All you need is to be in the moment. Feel the fear and do it anyway. You would not use these words, would you? The loss and change are real. It is visible. It is material. Yet, when it comes to substance use, depression or a recently received diagnosis, people start saying things like “you choose”, “it is your decision”, “you just have to do it”, “you just have to get up”, “you just have to stay positive”, “you just have to stop feeling sorry for yourself”. You just have to…

It does not work that way. It is not that simple. When you have a physical problem with your legs, eyes or ears, the medical model will usually have a good idea of what it is, what you can and can’t do or rather how. Once you accept it that life has changed, and the physical world has changed, you start recovering. What is next? How can I get one? Can I get an artificial one? Can I get a wheelchair? Glasses? And once it is there, then you can start saying it is up to you how high you will jump and how far you will travel. 

But hidden disabilities are not an exact science. Not yet. Probably never will be. Does it matter? We do not see the brain; misdiagnosis and overshadowing are real problems. But denying its very existence does not help either because it puts all the responsibility on our shoulders. Telling us that we have not tried hard enough. That it is our fault. 

They are real. Your condition, your pain, your loss, your healing, your recovery, your…

Medical and social. Probably both. Probably none. The whole approach seems to be somewhat faulty and limiting. Why is it that we cannot accept something until it can be counted, measured, drawn or any way represented by instruments? Receiving a diagnosis, when your psychiatrist looks at you and tells you “You have a disability. You have …” does not feel right. The medical model does put you in a box and labels you. But it also helps and gets you a framework. Every label comes with a manual. It does help stop you from fighting. But it does not mean you are not good enough. It does not mean you will never change. It does help stop you from desperately wanting to fit in. To become someone you have never been and possibly never would be. We need the other side, that will tell you what you can do, what you are good at, how others can accommodate you, to get out of the box. But if your brain is wired differently, if it might never learn certain things, then it brings relief knowing it. We need to stop fighting, curing, ranking, selecting…

Some say they do not like the word disability because it means you cannot learn. And we all can, but some just need more time. Yes, we can learn many things, but possibly not everything. Giving false hopes and wanting desperately to achieve something that was not for you does not help either. Instead, knowing your strengths and limitations and, most importantly, learning when and how to ask for help may offer more. 

Do not put yourself in a box. Never give up advancing further. But do not fight any longer, either. Learn to shape your world according to your needs. Work on the aspects you can work with. And help the world to learn to accommodate your weaknesses and celebrate your strengths. This is how the medical and the social should work together. Supporting people and the community to understand that all of us have strengths and weaknesses. 

Let us give the world our strengths, and let us ask the world to help us live well with our weaknesses because this will bring the greatest benefit to all of us. People who live with various mental difficulties – learning disabilities or autism or depression or obsessions – are unique and precious individuals. They are full of love and full of fun and full of life and full of....find out yourself.
An interesting blog post about the importance of considering autistic people’s functioning and daily experiences in various environments. Professionals aim to establish the 'core sets' of autism to specify the essential abilities and disabilities associated with autism. Original article.

In summary:

A multidisciplinary team was set up to create a core set for autism based on, first, a systematic literature review that analysed 71 autism studies, from which 99 relevant categories of functioning were identified in the following domains: basic interpersonal interactions, complex interpersonal interactions, emotion, attention and language. Second, 225 experts were asked, and they highlighted 103 categories, such as complex interpersonal interactions, control of voluntary movement, and functioning with the immediate family. Third, people with autism, their families and carers were asked. Finally, they carried out a cross-sectional study of 122 people with the condition. Several core sets for autism were created, including a comprehensive core set, a brief core set and core sets for different ages. The group of professionals hope that the ICF core sets will be key in the functional assessment of autism, but they also add that their clinical utility is somewhat limited. They hope to develop further standardised diagnostic instruments, such as questionnaires and observation rubrics for different settings, so doctors, scientists and policy-makers can use these tools to assess functioning and disability in individuals with autism.

Critique of the paper and the state of autism research:

All these sound very promising and forward-thinking, yet one thing has not been mentioned at all in this article and other sources I could locate. And this one thing is gender differences. We know that autism, from its first recognition in the early 20th century, is male-biased both in research and diagnosis. The established and predicted ratio between males and females with autism by various research shows striking differences: it ranges from 9:1 to 2:1. In other words, every ninth person with autism is female or every second is female, and it is not quite the same. And this is worrying in this study, too, that there is no indication that they considered gender differences. 

Presumably, both females and males will have difficulties in social interaction. But let’s just offer two differences in the presentation that we can observe. First, females are much better with eye contact, and their non-verbal skills are less affected generally. Second, females are naturally better functioning in social situations thanks to their ability to mimic and smile, in other words, to pretend, so they can have advanced skills in hiding their difficulties and assimilating. So far, no specific guidance or protocol exists to support the diagnosis of females with autism. The chances remain high that they will be diagnosed with depression or bipolar disorder, and they often develop eating disorders with anorexia and/or bulimia nervosa. Many of them are probably in abusive relationships or abuse substances as a result of misdiagnosis/no diagnosis. Or because obsession and control are part of autism.

Is autism different in females, or do females possess some unique protective factors that mask/modify the presentation of the condition? How well do the present diagnostic tools work for females? Are females facing the same difficulties in school or employment? Does society react differently to females with autism than men with autism? And a couple of dozens of questions that should be investigated. Certainly one of my research interests.

I presume I am not the only person who seeks answers to the ultimate questions: Who am I? Where am I coming from and going to?

You can accept that our brain, through its physiology, can lead us to set ways. The brain is a biological-electrical-chemical miracle. Moreover, it is claimed that our next steps can be predicted from our brain waves. Well, before we could be aware of them.

I do work on my own brain though; I try to enhance its particular abilities while suppressing and modifying others; I try to push its limits. But which part of me is it, then, that actually decides which way to manipulate my brain? Is it also my brain, a different dimension of it, the pure physical entity, or is this the me I am so ambitiously looking for? I would love to think it is my free will.

Brain injury is a different task. Your free will becomes compromised and restricted, if not completely lost. We also know that we have many traits and genes that predispose us to do things in predefined ways. However, I cannot help but see myself and basically everything around me from a holistic and interrelated point of view. It is clear that the parts make up the whole, so researching the parts is crucial. We all feel tremendous gratitude towards people who have the ability to concentrate and research very specific fields: the neurons, the amygdala, the neurotransmitters, and the list is never-ending. They made and made an invaluable contribution to the whole. However, one could argue that the sum is purely the addition of the parts. And knowing how a part works in isolation means that it behaves the same way when it is part of a complex system. And modifying only one discrete segment has the same profound effect on the whole as attacking it from multiple directions would.

We already have an enormous breadth of knowledge and wisdom out there, but they exist in a kind of isolation. We do not know how they behave when they are together. How they adapt. How they complete each other. We need more systematic reviews or matrixes, algorithms to find out how they actually interact, work together in a holistic way.

I am not quite sure how, but the parts when come together could create a whole that becomes a much more powerful entity than merely just the sum of the parts. And the part can completely change in the whole. In fact, they might become less. as now they act with others. Hence it can give rise to superior abilities. I call it transcendent. Abilities that do not come from the addition of the pieces. At least not in a mathematical sense, where 1 plus 1 always equals 2. After agreeing what we mean by 1.

So, I am certainly all the experiences I had as a child; the ones that did happen to me, and the ones that did not but I believe they should have. And the ones I deny. They all shaped and continually shape me. Through a constant bidirectional dialogue with my biology. But are they really deterministic? Or can I and should I change anything I want? If so, how far we can and should go?

To a certain extent we can see the idea that we are our brain. But who is the one then who has the ability to learn how our perceptions work just to deceive it then? One of the great things, when you come to realise how you and your brain operates (and the rest of the system) is how to get the codes to manipulate it. To enhance it, deceive it, shape it. So let’s ask the question again: who is in charge then? I can and do manipulate my brain and performance. Well, I am experimenting with it. So I believe. But who is it then who has decided to do so? Are our values and morals that guide us on our journey are the pure physical brain, too?

I know my left, and I know my right. Ok, let’s say I have a considerable knowledge of them. I am pretty far from saying I know them. But I also experienced, or rather felt that something else is there, too. Paradoxically it is similar to the feeling that you have when you leave your brain to do the job without you; when you stop using either your left or right by will. However, it can be differentiated from the automatic system. I think.

I cannot quite name it, or describe it. But it is there. I call this part of my brain the me part. It is above and beyond materiality. Certainly, this is how it feels.

The 'real' me who is free from the present and past trends, including the actual scientific facts and discoveries that probably will not be here in a few tens or hundreds of years of time. The “real” me is free of the senses, thoughts and emotions. I still do not quite know how to evoke it, reach it and retain it at any minute I want though. But it is there.

So, is it my true self? Was it born and risen at a certain point from the brain or is it really just the end product of this extremely complex entity? Just another projection of it? Does it have anything to do with the brain at all?

I have just been thinking of a car. Not as complex as the human brain but it has plenty of parts. If you take away just a very short part of the connection that lies between the engine and the battery your car will never start. It still looks like a car, you can still sit inside, look through the window, but it will not take you anywhere. As soon as you replace this very small connection, the battery will be reunited with the engine and the car will start. But what you will have then is not simply a car. You get much more than simply an addition of the parts. You get status, freedom, joy, love and thousands of other things.

Further research is underway to explore our brain. We should be careful, though what conclusions we take from it. We still only concentrate on the obvious, on the material, logical and measurable part of it. The one that can be described by the mathematical tools of science. That is reasonable due to the current lack of other instruments and communication systems.

However, has not quantum physics already taught us and showed that there are other laws out there? Even if they are talking about the subatomic levels? Laws that have explained our world as upside down, inside out and given rise to theories that are so complex and absurd? They also taught us that just because we do not understand the whole process it does not mean that it is not there or not correct.

But let’s go back to the original question. Who am I? Am I simply the end product of my brain subtle biological, electrical and chemical games it plays? Does the self equate to the brain? Do values, free will, thinking, and soul exist?

Brain injuries do affect our world and abilities, so it is easy to see why the conclusion has been drown that we are our brain. Yes, we need a healthy brain to express the cognition talked about here. Have you ever tried to get rid of an addiction or lose weight? If so, you know the difference between what your brain dictates and what you do by free will. Or is it just a game of the hierarchies? I stopped smoking. The craving is there and can be ever so strong. Terrible, hardly bearable at times. But still. You can resist, you can fool it, and beat it. Can I, really?

In every moment, we have the option to choose what we will do next. Or is it also part of the game? Do we really choose or we follow our brain that makes us believe that we have choices? If I choose and not my brain then what happens after a brain injury? Where does this me go then? Are we that sure that it is not there just because we do not see it and hear it? Just because this appears to be the truth? Even if the person himself cannot find this part of him anymore, are we really that sure, that it is not there? Just because it cannot find its way to the surface anymore? People do recover from serious brain injuries. Some of them had to learn all the skills again such as reading or talking. Their personalities do change but not always and not everything. Some things remain untouched.

I would love to believe that this is me. And it is always there even if I am not aware of it.

But what we mean by me. Certainly not my emotions, thoughts, fears and hopes. These are just rather illusions.